Free Essay

West Point Case Study

In: Business and Management

Submitted By MrMojoRising
Words 801
Pages 4
West Point Case Analysis
Bellevue University

Description “A Cadet will not lie, cheat or steal nor tolerate those who do”, reads West Point’s honor code, allegedly violated in 1976. The West Point Cheating Incident revolves around an incident from 1976, where over 100 juniors were alleged to have cheated on an electrical engineering exam. Cheating on an exam can have damning ramifications at any school, but when it comes to West Point; it is a direct violation of the schools highly held honor code. The honor code is a West Point tradition, and has helped mold military leaders with high integrity and strong values. Due to the sheer number of individuals, who were alleged to be involved, and where the scandal was happening, the event garnered national attention. Due to the uproar in the press and across the country, more pressure was placed on General Sidney Berry, Superintendent of the United States Naval Academy by bureaucrats and politicians alike.
Diagnosis
West Point is not your ordinary school setting. It is a breeding ground for training our nation’s best and brightest future military leaders. In the United States Military, it is imperative for soldiers to lead with character, while remaining calm under fire. It seems West Point, at the time of this event, concerned itself more around punishing for crimes than it did developing character. If West Point was truly interested in developing leaders with high character, it would not utterly dismiss individuals for any perceived violation of the honor code. “[E]ach organization is embedded—more or less—in its own tradition, and the core virtues in one tradition will not necessarily be the same in another” (Dufresne & Offstein, 2012, p. 576). The storied traditions of West Point seem to have stymied the institution from keeping up with the times.

Theory In the 1990’s, there was a survey conducted of 6,000 students from 31 colleges, 14 schools had an honor code and 17 did not. It was found that students at schools with honor codes had less cheating; however, if the students believed their peers were behaving with integrity as well, there was even less cheating (Dufresne & Offstein, 2012, p.576). Based upon this statistic, the honor code does have a place in West Point society, as well as helping maintain character development in future military officers. Simply because there is a violation of the honor code should not immediately require dismissal from West Point. One way to look at this would be in resiliency development. Our military is tasked to overcome numerous almost insurmountable obstacles. Soldiers can find themselves in the pits of despair, but are forced to dig deep and are forced to “focus on resilient thoughts based on their assessment of their resources and options to overcome adversity” (Luthans, 2011, p.223). By knocking a cadet who violates the honor code down a peg or two will force him to re-evaluate the playing field and develop a new plan to move forward. It could be seen as a turning point in the individual’s military career and life.
Prescription
I would recommend a tiered punishment system be enacted for those who violate the honor code. There should be different levels of punishment depending upon the offense. The punishment would be decided upon by a panel consisting of peers, alumni, and administration officials. The exact composition of said board could be decided upon at a later date. By providing more flexibility in the punishment system, it would allow for West Point to further develop strong character in its cadets. In this case, West Point dismisses the candidate, and the investment made into the individual is lost. Keeping the cadet could prove to be a better fiscal decision.
Fallout
The first group that would immediately want answers would be alumni who had to make it through the strict guidelines and honor code. The alumni will want to make sure West Point maintains its reputation for molding men of integrity and valor. What the alumni will need to understand is that just like the military and every other organization, occasionally change is required. West Point would be able to find themselves having more flexibility in molding the cadets as well. The applicants they have are some of the brightest young minds available. These applicants also have very strong morals, values and are known as high character individuals. Occasionally, there is a break down in decision-making, which leads to mistakes. Being able to learn from these mistakes and become better leaders will certainly prove valuable.

References
Dufresne, R.L. & Offstein, E.H. (2012). Holistic and intentional student character development process: Learning from west point. Academy Of Management Learning & Education, 11(4), 570-590.
Luthans, F. (2011). Advanced organizational behavior. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill Companies.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

West Jet Case Analysis

...unique opportunities and threats for management. Similarly, the industry environment poses significant threats and opportunities fpr the airline. There is strong rivalry as WestJet closes in on Air Canada’s domination of Canadian market share. In addition, the relatively high purchasing power of both suppliers and buyers affects WestJet’s business decisions and operations. West Jet’s main core competency, its integrated cost-differentiation focus strategy and implementation, has proved to be a recession-proof solution that gains considerable media and business attention. This strategy, fully embraced by each WestJet employee, is designed to continuously identify new areas for growth, such as an additional low-capacity regional line to underserved markets and WestJet Vacations packages. Finally, the airline’s ability to liquidate assets quickly and maintain low leverage makes WestJet a very lucrative TSX investment. Mission Statement and Vision WestJet aims “to enrich the lives of everyone in West Jet's word by providing safe, friendly and affordable air travel. “By 2016, West Jet will be one of the five most successful international airlines in the world providing guests with a friendly and caring experience that will change air travel forever”1. 1.0 Political/Legal Extensive laws regarding airline safety and security, the provision of services, competition, and environmental and labour concerns govern Canada’s airline industry2.......

Words: 4430 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

A Case Study on the Difficulties Faced by Tm Point Kuala Selangor in Operating It Shop

...A CASE STUDY ON THE DIFFICULTIES FACED BY TM POINT KUALA SELANGOR IN OPERATING IT SHOP BACHELOR OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION WITH (HONS) OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT FACULTY OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT NOVEMBER 2009 AbstrAct ABSTRACT This case study will be conducted in TMpoint Kuala Selangor. I would like to identify the difficulties faced by this organization in operating it shop. As this company is a serviceoriented organization, they need to satisfy customer’s needs and wants. Sometimes, they fail to achieve due to some problems or lacking. In this case, I will use the customer’s data of fixed-line termination and monthly statistical data on customer complain to explore the symptoms of low customer satisfaction. I also will conduct some observations in order to gather relevant data. The computer software package which is Statistical Package for Social Science (SPSS student Version 14.0 for Window) will be used to analyze the data that have been gathered, furthermore to identify the major problems faced by this organization. There are some symptoms that has been identified; there are increasing number of customer complain, fixed-line termination, not well-educating the customers and shortage of worker. When the problem has been identified, conclusion and recommendations will suggested to the organization in order to be the best service provider in the world. They need to take corrective action if they want to ensure company’s survilvalness. vii TABLE OF CONTENT...

Words: 13705 - Pages: 55

Premium Essay

Points to Address in Precision Case Study

...Precision Worldwide, Inc case study. Begin by talking about the issues ….. Substantive Issues Raised. The primary issue at hand involves the relevant cost of a set of replacement parts. The parts, however, range from those that are totally manufactured and ready for sale, to those that have not yet been manufactured but for which raw material is on hand, to those that have not yet been manufactured and for which no inventory of raw material exists. The case solution turns in large part on the use of contribution analysis. However, the concepts of sunk costs, opportunity costs, and product substitution are prominent aspects of any reasonable analysis. The product in question, a steel ring, is used as a replacement part for industrial machines manufactured and sold by both Precision Worldwide, Inc and their competitors. It sells for $1,350 per hundred rings with annual sales of approximately 36,000 rings. One competitor, Henri Poulenc, has introduced a plastic ring. This ring lasts up to four times as long and is priced at about the same level as PWI’s product. Mr. Thorborg, the gm of the German plant of PWI, must analyze the data, the conflicting views of his sales manager and his development engineer, and make a decision as to whether PWI should begin the manufacture of a plastic ring. In addition, a plan needs to be designed as to the pricing policy to follow for both the steel and the plastic rings. Finally, some consideration should be given to the effect of......

Words: 778 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The West Point Cheating Scandal

...Case Analysis of “The Road to Hell” Kelly, Berger, McCants and Smith MBA 633 Summer Semester Bellevue University Description of the Case “Road to hell” is a case study by Gareth Evans, about two characters from different cultural backgrounds. John Baker who is a successful chief engineer of the Caribbean Bauxite Company of Barracania in the West Indies. John Baker is also, an English expatriate and is 45-years-old with 23 years with Continental Ore in the Far East. We will assume that he is of Caucasian decent and very well educated with all his experience and years on the job. John Baker thinks he has a knack for working in foreign countries because of his experience with the regional staff. Matt Rennalls, who is training to be John Bakers successor for the chief engineering position is also a young engineer who represents the newer generation and is highly intellectual by being one of the smartest prospects on the staff of Caribbean Bauxite- at London University where he took first-class honors in the BS engineering degree. Matt Rennalls years at London University also made him racially conscious and any sign of concerns involving his culture. The last meeting with these characters didn’t end well. Instead of Matt accepting the position as chief engineer, he declines and turns in a letter of resignation, because he felt insulted by John Bakers advice. As John read the letter he not only felt puzzled but he actually did not understand what he said that was so......

Words: 553 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Lenovo Case Study : East Meets West

...FULL NAME : LINH PHUONG TRAN STUDENT ID : BH12027 UOG ID : 000792235 MODULE CODE : BUSI1317 MODULE TUTOR : HA NGUYEN MODULE NAME : STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT COURSE : BA ( HON) BUSINESS MANAGEMENT INTAKE : MARCH 2013 TITLE : LENOVO EAST MEETS WEST OUTLINE TABLE CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION 4 II. LENOVO HISTORY AND VISION STATEMENT 4 III. LENOVO SWOT ANALYSIS 6 1. External factors (O- opportunity and T-threat) 6 2. Internal factors ( S- strength and W-weakness) 9 IV. LENOVO STRATEGIC CHOICES 13 V. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION 14 List of figure Figure | Name | page | 1 | The Lenovo history timeline | 4 | 2 | Lenovo vision statement | 5 | 3 | Porter’s Diamond model | 6 | 4 | Lenovo Porter’s Diamond model | 7 | 5 | Strength in Lenovo’s structure | 10 | 6 | Lenovo CAGE framework | 11 | 7 | Lenovo strategic implementation | 13 | 8 | strategic triangle | 14 | I. INTRODUCTION Thomas L.Friedman reminded to the term "Flat world" as the way to describe to an era of new World economy. Which including the globalization, intense competition, a big market without borders, the variety and combination of cultures in the World (Thomas L. Friedman, 2005; Victor K. Fung, el, at 2007; Ronald Aronica and Mtetwa Ramdoo, 2006). In fact, The change, updates, innovation and competition in technology industry are taking a level higher, because it happening every days, every hours (Jeffrey T. Macher, David C. Mowery; 2004).......

Words: 2711 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

West Point Cheating Incident Essay

...West Cheating Incident Case Running Head: West Point Cheating Incident Case Submitted By: Warren Frazier For: Advanced Organizational Behavior 1 April 2014 West Point Cheating Case Description The success of a major corporation depends primarily on the development and completion of its mission statement. In order to achieve success, make profits and remain competitive in today’s market. Most organizations accomplish its mission by hiring personnel with high integrity, trustworthy, and dedication. Organizations are proven to be more productive when there are employees who are totally committed to helping the company commitment for success. There are career fields which people put volunteer to put lives at risk. These are police officers, firefighters, and most important. Those who serve in our Armed Services who volunteer to help defend our great country. There are incidents that can happen when people make decisions, which jeopardize the mission, integrity, moral, & reputation of an organization. The cheating incident at WestPoint serves as an example of what can happen when you have a loss of institutional control and leadership. Theory The West Point cheating incident is a case, which centers around a breach in the integrity and honesty of its cadets. There report reveals the many factors, which contributed to the incident becoming a major problem for the service academy. ...

Words: 1429 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Jet Blue West Case Study

...1. WestJet upgraded first while JetBlue observed. JetBlue created a backup failover system and hired a temporary call center for help. The impact was that WestJet experienced (as a result of not being patient and not waiting) significant disruptions as JetBlue’s transition and implementation went smoothly. WestJet had to compensate passengers as a result of the erratic transition. 2. The precautions were taken by JetBlue in this case. They observed WestJet’s implementation and learned from their actions. Unlike WestJet, JetBlue also hired temporary call center workers to handle basic calls. Other actions taken by JetBlue include reduce and consolidating flights, as well as waiting for a slow travel period before implementing the upgrade. These precautions helped by allowing JetBlue’s experienced operators to handle the more complex calls during the upgrade (WestJet customers experienced long waits and travel reservation difficulties). Because of this, JetBlue only had to use its failover system twice and did not have to offer its passengers compensation to its customers, like WestJet did. 3. Upgrade advantages would include having many new features immediately available with faster future implementations and lower cost platforms as well as more support for mobile platforms. However, there would be some disadvantages that would come with upgrading also. Significant upfront expenses, and significant disruptions if not done in the proper manner are just......

Words: 325 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Case Study- West Point

...Description: Lt. General Sidney Berry, Superintendent of the United States Military Academy at West Point has been faced with a series of difficult decisions after being notified of underclassmen at the campus where caught cheating, a violation of the Cadet Honor Code with the Academy. All cadets that are found guilty by the Honor System are subject to expulsion. The decisions Berry is faced with raises issues concerning ethics, organizational adjustment and change, and action planning to tackle the arising conflict. Through acting in the best wishes of West Point’s standards, Lt. General Berry must also heavily consider the interests of the Department of the Army, Congress, West Point alumni, current cadets on campus, and the public with the gaining acknowledgement of the incident. Diagnosis: Throughout the incident, questions arised in a variety of avenues regarding West Point’s standards and the possibility of misalignment of the discipline displayed versus the objectives of the Academy. Questions such as whether the Honor Code was to general to the extent of not being able to evenly and fairly enforce conduct or whether constitutional guarantees of due process were considered during the adjudication of disputes arising under the Honor Code. This incident could also be simply a result of cadets pushing the limits of the Academy of what they are and aren’t able to get away with; much like a child is with his or her parental figures. Nevertheless, the integrity of......

Words: 585 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

North West Case Study

...The North West Company Push vs Pull The North West Company Executive Summary: The North West Company is a leading retailer of food and everyday needs in rural Canada.   They are currently using a “push” strategy with the category managers at headquarters analyzing trends, placing orders and allocating products to stores.  Inspired by Giant Tiger’s pull system, North West management was considering giving store managers more control over their inventory ordering by moving to a “pull” replenishment strategy.   Barry McLeod, Director of Procurement and Marketing, has been assigned with determining if this “Pull” strategy would be a better fit. In order to reduce the risk and capitalize on the benefits, North West should localize in the hands of Regional Retail Managers. This strategic change will be beneficial for North West as they would gain the required regional/store level knowledge while avoiding giving all the responsibility to local store managers and investing a large amount of dollars to support the pull system.  Table of contents: Contents Issue(s) Identification 1 Environmental & Root Analysis: 2 Alternatives and/or Options: 3 Recommendation: 4 Implementation: 5 Monitor: 6 Issue(s) Identification The North West Company is experiencing inventory management problems with unsold inventory piling up as well as experiencing stock outs resulting in lost sales.   They have not been able to increase their yearly inventory turns from 2.2, well......

Words: 313 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

West Point Case

...MBA 633 “West Point: The Cheating Incident” Case DESCRIPTION- “West Point: The Cheating Incident” case is about cadets that were accused of cheating on a take home exam at the United States Military academy at West Point. Over 100 juniors were involved in cheating scandal which made them in violation of the Cadet Honor Code. Anyone who violates such code is to be expelled from the Academy. 52 of the accused were found guilty and 48 appealed their cases. The cheating scandal brought about the attention of the media, press, and even caused for the involvement of the secretary of the army and congress. DIAGNOSIS- The cause of the problem stems from the vagueness of the Honor Code. The Honor Code simply states: “A cadet will not lie, cheat, or steal nor tolerate those who do.” The fact the Honor Code has a toleration clause makes the system code extremely difficult to enforce. The dilemma that Lt. General Berry, the Superintendent, had was whether to use the Code as a determination of guilt of the cadets or a more detailed and systematic method. During the case some of the accused cadets begin to write affidavits implementing their fellow classmates. They pointed out specific incidents of other cadets lying, cheating, and stealing. If the Honor Code does not allow toleration then that would mean that the other cadets would have to be tried for the violations of the code as well. THEORY- The theory that applies to this case is personal accountability. One of the things......

Words: 444 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

West Jet Case Analysis

...WESTJET CASE ANALYSIS Information technology is a revolution in itself. I perceive the blend of Information Technology with business strategy in collaboration with most apt IT governance is what is required for an organization to flourish and be in a win- win situation in the long run. In the case analysis of The West jet, we are going to see how IT, Business Strategy and IT governance can be utilized in upgrading an organization so that it provides better customer service and satisfaction. Analysis :- West Jet Airlines known for its "High Value and Low Fare" was working fine with its in- house small but efficient Information technology services(It worked as the integral growth of the West Jet) until it started facing hindrances in code share. The systems in the west jet were stand- alone systems and were not able to collaborate with the international Airlines Systems. Initially, West Jet selected Sabre to move to International reservation system but it was not commendable. There were some issues with the IT Infrastructure. I perceive not having an IT expertise at an executive level is a major drawback for any growing organization since the business strategies have to be in sync with the IT requirements. Realizing that, the CEO along with other executives signed a contract with Cheryl Smith to be the CIO for The West jet. Since The West jet wanted to use IT to move to next level so Cheryl was responsible for raising the IT systems and infrastructure at par with other......

Words: 1948 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Case in Point

...CASE STUDY: HOW HUMANS HAVE AFFECTED THE ANTARCTIC FOOD WEB Although the icy waters around Antarctica may seem an inhospitable environment, a complex food web is found there. The base of the food web consists of microscopic, photosynthetic algae present in vast numbers in the well-lit, nutrient-rich water. A huge population of herbivores—tiny shrimp like krill—eat these marine algae. Krill, in turn, support a variety of larger animals. A major consumer of krill is the baleen whale, which filters krill out of the frigid water. Baleen whales include blue whales, humpback whales, and right whales. Squid and fishes also consume krill in great quantities. These, in turn, are eaten by other carnivores: toothed whales such as the sperm whale, elephant seals and leopard seals, king penguins and emperor penguins, and birds such as the albatross and the petrel. Humans have had an impact on the Antarctic food web as they have had on most other ecosystems. Before the advent of whaling, baleen whales consumed huge quantities of krill. Until a global ban on hunting large whales was enacted in 1986, whaling steadily reduced the number of large baleen whales in Antarctic waters. As a result, of fewer whales eating krill, more krill became available for other krill-eating animals, whose populations increased. Now that commercial whaling is regulated, it is hoped that the number of large baleen whales will slowly increase, and that appears to be the case for some species. However, the......

Words: 638 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Case in Point

...different current levels of climate change. There is no scientific method that could have avoided Hurricane Katrina. Scientific research state that more extreme weather changes the forms of rainfall and drought can have an expressive impact on the environment. The proximity of Southern Louisiana and New Orleans, shelves the Gulf of Mexico that is a highly vulnerable area for storm surges and hurricane. The Mississippi River, Lake Borgne, and Lake Pontchartrain rise and always overflow during flood and hurricane. Hurricanes are natural disasters unprecedented for America. The fury of Mother Nature cannot be stopped; the tragedy of killer storm Katrina left devastating effects that was preventable. If society ever reaches a technological point where they can influence hurricanes and alternative solution can be implemented. The weakening of hurricanes would be advisable to control the environment over the upcoming decades. If this method works, as hurricane approach landfall then the flow of water flow would be cut off before it hit upstream. Changing the direction of flooding would be detoured to water where no human life inhabits. Louisiana sits below sea level where levees are erected to control flooding this issue proves to be fertile because this city is threatened every time the skies turn gray. New Orleans is built on unconsolidated sediment where there is no rock underneath this area, in other words the city sits on an area that has no good foundation. Another......

Words: 668 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Case in Point

...Case-In-Point In this global economy, energy is an important factor to stay competitive in the world. Solar energy, wind power, water sources, and fossil fuels are available these days. Human beings need to subdue the universe and transform these sources for a better life. The Arctic National Wildlife Refuge is a sleeping reserve of fossil fuels. The Yucca Mountain is storage for nuclear waste. The Three Gorges Dam in China is the biggest sources of hydroelectricity in the world. How viable is each of sources of energy? Is the exploitation indefinite? What is the environmental impact in the ecosystem? Which one of the sources is the best based on ethical and economical issues? The Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR) is a fossil fuel and natural gas energy source located in Alaska, USA. The fossil fuels reserve is very abundant. According to the US geological survey, on a 1980 research, ANWR has 17 billions of barrels of oils and 34 trillions of Natural Gas. The environmental impact, if it exists, is minimum; only 8% of the refuge will be used, and the maximum footprint development allowed by Congress is about 2000 acres. The new technology implemented at Prudhoe Bay has made the area more environmental friendly for wildlife. In order to protect the tundra, drill sites are constructed on 4' thick gravel pads. Even if a 1" drop of crude oil drips onto the pad, workers are required to shovel it up for proper disposal. (Prudhoe Bay,......

Words: 1193 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

South West Airlines Case Study

...Case: _______Southwest Airlines 2002___________ Name____Kacey Kurtz__________________________ Southwest Airlines is currently competing in the airline industry. The company’s currency strategy is to carefully advertise its image so that consumers can clearly differentiate Southwest Airlines from other airlines. Southwest Airlines does this by being the only low fare, high frequency, short-haul, and point-to-point carrier in America. Southwest Airlines low fares creates brand equity, because consumers want low fares, and Southwest Airlines is one of the only major airlines that offers this attribute to consumers. Southwest Airlines was also the first airline to offer the frequent flyer program where flyers get credit for the number of trips taken and not the number of miles flown. Since Southwest offers low fares and short travel customers may see that flying is a better alternative than traveling in a car. Some outside conditions that affected Southwest Airlines was deregulation which made the airline industry much more competitive. Everything dealing with air travel is regulated by the government now. Airlines operate in a highly competitive environment where fixed costs are very high and this made it one of the toughest industries to compete in without a lot of airlines going bankrupt. Fuel cost were outrageous that were out of airlines control. Airlines had to fund a lot more towards security since the 911 crisis to keep passengers protected and they...

Words: 1415 - Pages: 6