Premium Essay

Walmart Dilema

In: Business and Management

Submitted By donniebellew
Words 1394
Pages 6
One of the main ethical dilemmas that a store manager working for Wal-Mart might be faced with is a conflict of interest. He/she has been placed into a situation where there is no right or wrong answer, but rather a right, and right answer. Does he choose the role of being a good manager, and risk the managerial position? Or does he act upon the “unethical” commands of his superiors in favor of keeping his job? Three underlying elements further complicating his decision to make ethical choices are discussed in this essay. These are identified as self interest, greed, and obedience to authority, and will be discussed using Ghillyer’s three-step process of analyzing the consequences, analyzing the actions, and making a decision where the ethical dilemma can be resolved, or at least diminished.
Self interest could have been a contributing factor to his decision making, which resulted in a class-action lawsuit, costing the company $50 million. Self interest can be categorized under one of the three ethical theories, virtuous ethics, which places its value in living life according to the commitment to the achievement of a clear ideal. For example, “What sort of person would I like to become?” An ideal goal for the manager could be to provide a shelter, clothing, and food for himself and/or his family. These are the basic innate impulses or drives in human beings, that explain the well known evolutionary theory of Survival of the Fittest. In the Wal-Mart example, this is demonstrated by the manager attempting to benefit himself by taking as many incentives (money) offered by the corporation, despite the unethical methods involved. These incentives are annual bonuses for the managers of the stores that remain within the Total Payroll Expense. The methods used to stay within this report included; “Off-the-Clock Work” where employees were forced to work after clocking out,…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Walmarts Reputation

...for Wal-Mart is committed to fostering open and honest dialogue with elected officials, opinion makers and community leaders that conveys the positive contributions of Wal-Mart to working families. We believe that Wal-Mart provides value to its customers, to its associates and to the communities it serves (cite working ppl 4 walmart). The advocacy groups claim this cite was created for Wal-Mart to speak out on complaints it is facing. This website is still utilized on Wal-Mart’s website today. It was later discovered that Working Familes for Wal-Mart was actually funded by Wal-Mart itself rather than a third party. This situation should have been handeled completely different. Rather than showing a separate company doing this Wal-Mart should have taken responsibility alerting the the public that in efforts to keep this from happening in the future we are taking action. That would have shown the public that they are really tring and were owning up to their mistakes. They should have known that the advocacy groups would have dug up this information and report it to the public. It is very interesting to see how corporations handle the ethical dilemas that it faces. Often times it seems that by being so large they do everything right until employees begin to speak out and the media get a hold of the information. The public then becomes aware of how badly these corporations are actually conducting business. It seems that Wal-Marts rapid growth hurt them in the long......

Words: 1431 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Walmart

...Walmart: Global Strategic Expansion - Executive Summary Since introducing its first international store in 1991, Walmart has transformed itself from an American retail giant into a global one, leveraging a wealth of resources to strategically expand operations. Although Walmart must contend with several formidable competitors, the retailer has successfully opened thousands of stores across the globe; most frequently, it has added international units through the acquisition of foreign retailers, which simultaneously reduces its competition and furthers its dominance. Walmart has differentiated itself by coupling its understanding of political, economic, legal, and cultural systems within target markets with its low-cost, high-quality approach to mass retail. Utilizing simultaneous strategic multiple thrusts, Walmart has developed layers of competitive advantage to establish itself as the world’s leading retailer. Focusing on strategic expansion, Walmart currently operates 9,826 stores across twenty-eight countries, allowing it to capture global scale efficiencies by creating a coordinated and integrated network of interdependent stores. Each unit within its network is regarded as a source of ideas and capabilities, and innovation is diffused across the company through initiatives such as a market-by-market training program that helps increase the company’s responsiveness to local demands and preferences. Thus, Walmart has established itself as a transnational corporation by......

Words: 5506 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Walmart

...From this perspective, Walmart operates under the philosophy and strategy of continuously enhancing their processes, so they can offer low prices for their customers and clients, which in return allows them to have a better life by saving money in any store. However, their social responsibility goes even beyond their commitment to customers. It extends into the community and around the world. Walmart has initiatives to make a difference on issues like preserving the environment, fighting hunger, and as stated above, improving the lifestyle of the community by providing access to healthy and affordable food. According to Walmart’s website, the company achieved ten goals at the end of 2011, goals that relate to society and to being a socially responsible corporation. These achievements were: * Reduction of waste by 80%, on all of its US operations. * Expansion of locally grown produce. With this goal, Walmart increased the amount of locally grown produce (produce grown and sold in the same state) by 97%, and it now accounts for more than 10% of all produce sold in US stores. * Support of women around the world. Walmart committed to sourcing $20 billion from women-owned business in the US. * Saved customers $1 billion on fresh fruits and vegetables. * Announced Great for You icon, which helps consumers to easily and quickly identify healthier food options. * Utilized 1.1 billion kWh of renewable energy, which has allowed Walmart to be recognized as......

Words: 2018 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Walmart

...It's Just Walmart". The New York Times. Retrieved on November 21, 2012. 2. Stevenson, Mark. (November 4, 2004). "Despite months of protests, Walmart-owned store opens near Mexico's pyramids". San Diego Union-Tribune. Retrieved on November 21, 2012 3. McKinley, Jr., James C. (September 28, 2004). "No, the Conquistadors Are Not Back. It's Just Walmart". The New York Times. Retrieved on November 21, 2012. 4. (February 13, 2007). "Walmart / Lowe's Shopping Center Destroys Native American Cemetery". Alliance for Native American Indian Rights. Retrieved on November 21, 2012. 5. Stone, Kenneth E. (1997). "Impact of the Wal-Mart Phenomenon on Rural Communities". (Published in Proceedings: Increased Understanding of Public Problems and Policies – 1997. Chicago, Illinois: Farm Foundation). Iowa State University. Retrieved November 21, 2012 6. "Walmart Stores, Inc. vs. American Drugs, Inc.: Arkansas Supreme Court Decision". (Case No. 94-235). Arkansas Supreme Court. January 9, 1995. Retrieved on November 21, 2012 7. Staff Writer. (August 1, 2002). "Mexico Investigates Walmart for Antitrust Violations." The Hometown Advantage. Retrieved on November 21, 2012. 8. Staff Writer. (February 1, 2003). "German High Court Convicts Walmart of Predatory Pricing". The Hometown Advantage. Retrieved on November 21, 2012. 9. "Store Wars: When Walmart Comes to Town." PBS. Retrieved on November 21, 2012 10. Keil, Stanley R., Spector, Lee C. The Impact of Walmart on......

Words: 5612 - Pages: 23

Free Essay

Walmart

...Walmart Walmart, one of the great stories in American history but, how does it compare to other retail stores like Target or K-mart, but, it also has a history of discrimination toward women and minorities. Mr. Sam Walton, a military man, a captain in World War II could not have imagined that his business would grow into one of most productive retail stores in modern history. Even today, with Walmarts, overseas, Walmart has cornered the retail market by storm. But, it also has a bad image, over its business deals against women and minorities and especially not giving equal pay for equal work, or denying workers the opportunities for advancements that are offered to white males in his business. I guess this wouldn’t be Mr. Walton, but his board of governors should be held accountable. Everyday people file law suits against the company, how long will the company last? Next, they have become so large that they can afford to move overseas, and hire workers that will work for less than the average American will, now, that will be exactly what was needed for the company,(globalization.) Walmart has stores in countries that the common American has never heard of. In the 1940’s, a young man named Sam Walton, of Newport, Arkansas, was using another stores business model, and that was, get products at a reasonable price, and they had to be American made. His idea was so simple anybody could have done it, but anyway, his idea was to look for bargain deals from suppliers and sell......

Words: 2501 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Walmart

...Walmart Slide1 Welcome to our presentation, our topic is Walmart, I will present the pro arguments for Walmart and Cherrif will present the arguments against Walmart. Slide 2 First of all I want to say some basic facts about walmart. Sam Walton created walmart in the year 1962 and he opened the first walmart in the same year in 1962 in Arkansas. Today we can say walmart has more than 9000 stores worldwide and its spread over 15 countries. Think about it for a second Sam Walton created walmart only 50 years ago and the company has over 2 million employees. That is amazing. Slide 3 Now you can see a quote from Sam Walton about Walmart. Slide reading. That is everything what expect from a store for customers. Slide 4 Some more facts: it is the worlds lagest public corporation by revenue. Furthermore the largest private employer in the world. A really important part in walmart is the grocery part, it is the largest grocery seller in the US and it is friendly to children you can see it in the fact that walmart is the largest toy seller in the us. Slide 5 Walmart has not only toys or a big grocery part, walmart brings low prices and the conveniece of shopping at one place, where you can find everything. You dont have to go to different stores to buy, walmart has everything what you need. You save a lot of time to go to walmart and buy there. Plus the walmart prices are between 15% and 22% less expenisive than the market price/ the other stores. And it is open...

Words: 689 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Walmart

...Walmart has a social responsibility to people around the world. One of those responsibilities, is to help save them money. Millions of people enter through the doors of Walmart or their other stores to spend hundreds, even thousands of dollars. If Walmart didn’t have such reasonable prices, people couldn’t spend that money and be able to afford what they need or want. Walmart has been the number one leader in the retail industry for many years and has been able to keep their doors open and grow into an empire because of consumer spending. Since Walmart sells many different food items, they made a decision to make their food healthier and more affordable for their customers. They are in the process of reformulating some of their packaged food with reducing the sodium by 25 percent and the added sugars 10 percent. They are working with sellers to improve their nutritional and superiority value also. When consumers go into Walmart to shop, this isn’t something that is hunted, but Walmart is doing what they can to make a healthier you. They also feel that you shouldn’t have to decide on the food that is healthy or food that someone can afford, so they are taking actions to make sure that the healthier food is more affordable. The Walmart foundation gives throughout the world to help fight hunger. They have donated 2 billion dollars to in 2012, to start what was called Expand Backpack Programs that is filling backpacks and are provided on Friday afternoons that are......

Words: 310 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Walmart

...Cost Leadership and Differentiation Strategies @Walmart Submitted by: Samrat Basu INDEX PAGE Walmart Origin Page-3 Walmart Mission/Vision Page-4 Corporate Culture@ Walmart Page-4 Competitive Position of Walmart Page 5-6 Strategies @ Walmart Page 6-9 Private Label and Store Layout Page 9-11 Conclusion Page-11 Appendix Page 12 References and Bibliography Page 13-14 Wal-Mart- Origin Wal-Mart was the product of Sam Walton, a businessman from Arkansas. In the late 1940s, in USA, a retailer who was successful in obtaining a sufficient discount for his products from the whole-seller, used to sell the products at full price to the customers and thus enjoyed a substantial amount of profit. Sam Walton during that time was working as a retailer at a J.C. Penney store in Des Moines, Iowa.(Walton & Huey, 1993) Incidentally while working there, he was introduced to Butler Brothers, a big retailer who had chains of variety stores known as Ben Franklin and Sam was......

Words: 4491 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Walmart

...A local business that I frequent is Walmart. I go there on almost a weekly basis to get groceries and other necessities. The three main components of a business model are its business commerce, business occupation, and business organization. Business as a commerce is the process in which people produce, exchange, and trade goods and services. Walmart’s business commerce is trade. As Walmart has expanded, they are engaged in not only the trade of goods, but also services. Most Walmart stores have a variety of services that are provided, from a pharmacy, to a photo studio, hair care salon, etc. Business as an occupation is the set of skills and abilities that an organization has that allows them to create value in the goods and services that they offer. In the case of Walmart, a highly efficient set of skills and abilities exist. The company is set up to encourage efficiency and mass purchasing power, which allows Walmart to undercut its competitor’s pricing. Furthermore, Walmart invests significant amounts of money in employee training, which further supports the skill set of the business. Business as an organization is the system of authority and relationships that control interactions between people and move the organization towards a common goal. Walmart’s organization is one of its strong points, as it is organized according to a divisional structure, utilizing a market structure. Walmart, over the years, has greatly expanded its market structure, which allows it to......

Words: 255 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Walmart

...Walmart Manages Ethics and Compliance Challenges Sanelesia Hawkins West Georgia Technical College Abstract Despite its financial success and international proliferation, Walmart and its business practices have generated controversy and divided public opinion. Supporters praise Walmart’s sales of needed household items and groceries at relatively low prices, while critics condemn the corporation’s generally low wages paid to employees and its tendency, as a big-box retailer, to put small, community-based stores out of business. As a result, Walmart is often the subject of intense social and political debates pertaining to capitalistic practices and ethical treatment of workers. Another major criticism of the company pertains to its long history of allegedly “invading” smaller towns and communities, establishing stores, and thereby driving small, family-owned and -operated stores out of business because they were unable to compete financially. Walmart Manages Ethics and Compliance Challenges Walmart has been criticized by many groups and individuals, including labor unions and other groups. It has been accused of selling merchandise at such low costs that competitors have tried to sue it for predatory pricing (intentionally selling a product at low cost in order to drive competitors out of the market). Over the last decade or so Walmart has become involved in numerous lawsuits for a variety of reasons. The majority of the suits are class action lawsuits in which......

Words: 873 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Walmart

...UNIVERSITI KUALA LUMPUR BUSINESS SCHOOL ECB30103 STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT GROUP ASSIGNMENT: WALMART PREPARED BY: GROUP MEMBER 1) NURSYAHIDAH BINTI RAZALI 62283113720 2) NURUL NABILAH BINTI RAZALI 62283313248 3) NURUL ZAITUN BINTI ABDUL MALIK 62283313168 4) UMMI KHALSUM BINTI RAHMAT 62283313053 PREPARED FOR: LECTURER’S NAME: MOHD HAIZAM BIN MOHD SAUDI 1. What is the nature of the company business? What are their product lines? Wal-Mart is the World's largest retailer. It has over 11,500 stores in 28 countries across the globe. Wal-Mart is an American multinational retail corporation that operates a chain of hypermarkets, discount department stores and grocery stores. Walmart products include discount stores, cash and carry wholesale, warehouse club, super-center, supermarket and superstore and also an e-commerce business. 2. Develop a suitable vision and mission statement for the company. Vision i. To be the best retailer in the hearts and mind of consumer and employees. ii. To promote ownership of Wal-Mart ethical culture to all stakeholder globally. Mission i. Saving the people's money so they can live better. ii. If we work together we will lower the cost of living for everyone. iii. Save money. Live better. 3. Using the following template, develop EIGHT (8) core business objectives in fulfilling the stakeholder’s expectation. Please......

Words: 7815 - Pages: 32

Premium Essay

Walmart

...| Walmart | | | | | Danielle S Holley | 11/28/2011 | | Firms choose from different business-level strategies in order to proposer in today’s markets. One of these being the Cost Leadership Strategy, an integrated set of actions taken to produce goods or services with features that are acceptable to customers at the lowest cost, in comparison to their competitors. Firms that chose to use this strategy must sell standardized goods and services which have to also include competitive levels of differentiation to the market’s regular customers. Cost leaders have to examine all support activities to find extra resources in order to cut production costs allowing them to maintain low costs for their customers. In any industry fixed and variable costs can cause companies to go out of business. Cost Leadership Strategy can put a strain on companies because they have to keep developing new technology that can support low cost goods and services (with differentiation) as well as low production costs to satisfy the needs of customers in the market place. Using this strategy effectively can earn firms above-average returns in spite of rivals in the industry. Having the low-cost position in an industry is valuable way to deal with competitors. The cost leader’s strategic position causes competitors to think twice before they compete on the basics of price and technology against the potential outcomes of such competition (Hitt). Walmart is known for its......

Words: 5753 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

Walmart

...Walmart has endured great criticism for challenging the market in competitive pricing and selection. Walmart is a success because it sells products at low prices that people want to buy, satisfying customer's wants and needs. However, critics argue at the same time Walmart's lower prices draw customers away from other smaller businesses, hurting communities. Walmart offers consumers a choice, and the overall benefits to the economy outweigh any negative, natural affects of a competitive market The claim that Walmart's low prices causes some existing businesses to close is not political issue, it is the nature of capitalism. Despite all the criticism, this conglomerate continues to grow. I am thankful that our economy is based on capitalism. I am free to work for whom want or open a business; set my own prices and succeed- or fail. I am free to buy from Walmart or any other store I choose. It seems to me that Walmart is helping our economy thru this recession. Many people are saving money by shopping at Walmart, which in turn keeps many others working. Walmart is not the only one who seems to take the heat for its industry, McDonald’s faces similar disparagement for the fast food industry. Many critics use McDonalds as an example to attack the “unhealthy” food served in fast food industry. Both have responded well with tactics to directly counter-act the bad publicity. Walmart has made great efforts to improve its sustainability with new transportation and building......

Words: 303 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Orgaizational Dilemas

...ESTUDIOS DILEMAS ORGANIZACIONALES … suministro de materias primas y el dinero producto de la comercialización12 . Los centros de cultivo, procesamiento y distribución están en América Latina, los mercados en los países industrializados. Aquí se realizan las grandes transacciones que se traducen en flujos importantes de divisas hacia los países productores y sus economías; los efectos en el empleo y los ingresos en los países latinoamericanos no pueden, por tanto, subestimarse 13 . 12 DILEMAS ORGANIZACIONALES DE LAS ECONOMÍAS ILEGALES Aproximaciones sociológicas a propósito de la industria de la cocaína * RAINER DOMBOIS** La globalización acelerada de la economía, que se manifiesta en la expansión del comercio mundial, en el aumento de la importancia de los mercados financieros, en la ampliación de las actividades de las empresas transnacionales y en la difusión de nuevas tecnologías en las comunicaciones, tiene también otra cara menos visible: la globalización de los negocios ilegales. También el comercio ilegal ha cobrado impulso, ampliado su rango de influencia y configurado complejas estructuras por doquier, valiéndose de la apertura de las fronteras nacionales y de la liberación creciente del tráfico de bienes, capital y personas entre regio nes económicas hasta ahora incomunicadas, especialmente entre regiones con niveles elevados de bienestar. La aparición de grupos criminales que organizan el comercio y se caracterizan por su violencia, está también......

Words: 8357 - Pages: 34

Premium Essay

Walmart

...Week Four - Business Analysis Part I Before we conduct a SWOT analysis on Walmart, I want to give a brief history of the company. Walmart was founded in 1962 in Bentonville, Arkansas. Sam Walton’s vision was to achieve high volume of sales by maintaining sales price lower than competitors, which meant he had to reduce his profit margins. This multinational organization has been an example of growth, stability, profitability, and leadership in the retail business. The company is the second largest public corporation in America on the list of Fortune 500 in 2012 with 446,950 million dollars in revenue and $15,669 million dollars in profit (CNN Money, 2012). SWOT Analysis Strengths * The biggest private employer in the world (CNN Money, 2012). * Low price leader in the market since the beginning. * Second America’s largest corporation in 2012 (CNN Money, 2012). * One stop shop. Wide range of products under one roof. * Worldwide presence with more than 10,000 stores in 27 countries (Duke, 2012). * Leverage in the marketplace because of high purchasing volume. Weaknesses * Criticized of low paying jobs to its employees. * Limited grow opportunities to its employees. * Deficiency in the upscale market. * Adverse effects on small business in local community * Suppliers have to cut margins to sell their merchandise. * Monopolistic business. Opportunities * Pursue new international markets, especially in Asia and...

Words: 1302 - Pages: 6