Free Essay

Sailing Ship Effect

In: Computers and Technology

Submitted By glitterbella
Words 586
Pages 3
MGMT002: Technology & World Change

AY 2009-2010, Term 2

Student Paper Review, Howells (2002)
The response of old technology incumbents to technological competition
– Does the sailing ship effect exist?

Howells presents the audience with a critical view of the ‘sailing ship effect’ and postulates that it is triggered by misinterpretations based on insufficient knowledge, and that the mere existence of this effect is rare. This ‘sailing ship effect’ is the process whereby the advent of a new technology engenders a response aimed at improving the incumbent technology. I am inclined to Howells’ view and will further demonstrate this below. There is evidence to believe that the sailing ship effect is existent in the world today. Cooper and Schendel (1988) considered 7 different cases and I would like to focus on the case between vacuum tubes and the transistor. A simple timeline of the development of the vacuum tubes has shown that the old technology (vacuum tubes) continued to be improved and reached its highest stage of technical development only after the new technology (transistor) was introduced. Nonetheless, there is still insufficient evidence to definitely conclude that the sailing ship effect did take place. The sailing ship effect is challenged due to the number of externalities involved in the technological development of any product, making it difficult to conclude that accelerated improvements made by incumbent technology is driven solely by the emergence of new ones. Granted, there is a timely connection between the arrival of new technologies and the accelerated improvement of old ones, however, one must question the genuine motivation for this action (government funding, ‘normal’ intra-industry competition, lock-in effect or arrival of new technology). The Flettner rotor ship, for example, was a ‘government-inspired’ project.
Research and Development (R&D) is essential in the improvement of any technology. The availability of funds is a problem many firms face, however, with high barriers to entry coupled by financial support from the government, it is not difficult to understand how this could provide the impetus for accelerated improvement of a technology as a firm would want to gain monopoly in the industry. In the Alkali industry, the Claus-Chance process was already in the works before the threat of the Leblanc process. This shows that even without the presence of new technologies, accelerated improvements are still being made. I believe that the extent of the sailing ship effect can also be related to the substitutability of the old and new technologies. The more substitutable the new technology is, the greater need to invest in the improvement of the old technology to maintain competitiveness in the market (assuming the firm does not exit the industry or switch from old to new technology). This could be a factor, which allows the coexistence of both old and new technology. The advancement of cameras today illustrates the aforementioned idea. Despite the technological advancement of cameras (from film to digital), digital cameras and film cameras still coexist in the market because of their relatively low substitutability (as film photography is different from that of digital photography). It would be fallacious to argue that the lack of evidence of the sailing ship effect would mean that it is non-existent. Therefore, I do not believe that this effect is non-existent but support Howells’ viewpoint on the rarity of the sailing ship effect because it is too superficial to claim that the advent of new technologies provided the main driving force for the accelerated improvement of old technologies.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Ship Structures

...Ship Design and Construction Written by an International Group of Authorities Thomas Lamb, Editor Volume II Y OF NA IET VA C O L CHITECT AR S & RINE E NG MA I The Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers 601 Pavonia Avenue • Jersey City, NJ • 07306 THE ERS S NE • Published in 2004 by Copyright © 2004 The Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers. ISBN 0-939773-41-4 The opinions or assertions of the authors herein are not to be construed as official or reflecting the views of SNAME. It is understood and agreed that nothing expressed herein is intended or shall be construed to give any person, firm, or corporation any right, remedy, or claim against SNAME or any of its officers or members. Design by Andrew MacBride. Printed in the United States of America by Sheridan Books. Contents Acknowledgments ix xv Author Biographies for Volume II Chapter 27 Multipurpose Cargo Ships 27.1 Description 27-1 27.4 References 27-35 Horst Linde, Berlin University of Technology, Faculty of Transport Technology, Institute of Land and Sea Transport, Germany 27.2 Design Issues 27-28 27.3 Ship Characteristics 27-35 Chapter 28 Reefer Ships Allan M. Friis, The Technical University of Denmark, Denmark 28.3 Design Issues 28-26 28.1 Description 28-1 28.2 System Design 28-8 28.4 Ship Characteristics 28-27 Chapter 29 Oil Tankers Michael Osborne, Shell International Trading and Shipping, UK, and R. Keith Michel, Herbert......

Words: 11349 - Pages: 46

Free Essay

Battle Ships

...Latorre was officially ordered on 2 November 1911, and was laid down less than a month later on 27 November,[9][12] becoming the largest ship built by Armstrong at the time.[13] The New York Tribune reported on 2 November 1913 that Greece had reached an accord to purchase Almirante Latorre during a war scare with the Ottoman Empire,[14] but despite a developing sentiment within Chile to sell one or both of the dreadnoughts, no deal was made.[15][16][N 2] Almirante Latorre was launched on 27 November 1913,[18][19][N 3] in an elaborate ceremony that was attended by various dignitaries and presided over by Chile's ambassador to the United Kingdom, Agustín Edwards Mac Clure. The battleship was christened by the ambassador's wife, Olga Budge de Edwards.[10] After the First World War broke out in Europe, Almirante Latorre was formally purchased by the United Kingdom on 9 September 1914;[9][18][20][21] she was not forcibly seized like the Ottoman Reshadieh and Sultan Osman I, two other ships being built for a foreign navy, because of Chile's "friendly neutral" status with the United Kingdom.[20] fter the end of the war in Europe, Chile began to seek additional ships to bolster its fleet. The United Kingdom offered many of its surplus warships, including the two remaining Invincible-class battlecruisers.[N 4] The news that Chile could possibly buy a ship to compete...

Words: 303 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Best Cruise Ship

...BEST CRUISE SHIPS Allure of the seas The biggest cruise ship ever constructed can carry 6,360 passengers and beats Oasis of the Seas by a mere 5 centimeters in length! Oasis of the seas Another water-wonder from Royal Caribbean, Oasis of the seas is the sister ship of Allure of the seas and debuted in December 2009. Norwegian Epic Norwegian Cruise Line’s (NCL) Epic debuted in June 2010 and has been a favorite with passengers ever since. Innovation has been a catalyst in making Epic’s journey a hit with people. Solo studio cabins, ice-bar, performances by Blue-man group, new wave cabins and translucent bathrooms; the innovative changes are a pleasant change. Queen Mary 2 The first ever cruise line to be built for transatlantic voyage, QM2 was always regarded as the biggest cruise line in the world till Allure of the seas comfortably took its place on the number one spot. Since QM2 is used to cross the Atlantic Ocean, it’s designing and construction is a bit different from the other cruise liners. Freedom of the Seas Ruler of the cruising world, Royal Caribbean has another winner in its kitty, Freedom of the seas. The first ship to feature a surf-simulator onboard, Freedom of the seas is considered one the best cruise liners in the world. Liberty of the seas Sister vessel of the Freedom ship, Liberty is the second largest ship on the seas, coming after the Oasis sisters. Cruising between the Mediterranean and the Caribbean, Liberty is actually not very different......

Words: 2368 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Famine Ships

...Name Class Professor Date The Famine Ships: A Wing and a Prayer The Famine Ships is a book written by Edward Laxton about the Irish exodus from their ravished homeland. The focus on the book is describing what it was like to travel on these ships across the Atlantic Ocean while encountering storms, icebergs, disease, and starvation. The trips were often long and horrifying for the passengers, but they were forced to make the journey due to worsening conditions in Ireland at the time. As the potato crop continued to fail, more and more Irish left their homeland for America and Canada on these famine ships. In search of a better existence, many Irish risked their lives by taking the 3,000-mile voyage on ships that weren’t fit for service. Many of them died from sickness, starvation or accidents while in route, yet they kept coming, for their fate at home was even worse. Between 1846 and 1851 emigration from Ireland to America and Canada increased drastically due to the deteriorating famine conditions in Ireland. When the potato crop failed in 1846, “more than 100,000 had crossed the Atlantic by year’s end” (Laxton 13). This mass evacuation of people required more ships than were available, so many ships were refitted in order to carry passengers one way and then freight the other. The living quarters beneath the ships were over crowded and unsanitary. Wooden boards were thrown together in the ship’s hold as makeshift bunks, and each passenger had a......

Words: 929 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

A Great Sailing Journal Entry

..."Pull in the Jib". "Sit farther inside the boat". "Roll more in the tacks". These are all things I hear on a day-to-day basis from my superiors during the school sailing race team. In the beginning of the season, commands being tossed at me just flew right by and I never had any idea what they were talking about. Now, as the sailing season comes to an end in only a few weeks, I actually know what people are talking about. I have sailed since I can remember, starting in Essex and working my way up to MSA, but never would I have realized how meticulous and precise you have to be with everything to achieve maximum speed going through the course. If the boat is leaning too much one way you lose speed. If you move the rudder too much you lose speed. If you don't recoil yourself back into the center of the boat in roll tacks you lose speed. It is incredibly annoying how easy it is to lose speed and how hard it is to keep going fast. Which is why I like it. I think what makes me like it is that sailing has always been a relaxing experience and now that I realized that it is actually one of the most taxing physical and mental sports out there, the difference between what I thought it was and now what I know it is just intrigues me. Part of me wants to just chill on the side of the boat with a lemonade or jump off for a swim every once and a while but another part of me wants drysuits and constantly bruised shins from hitting the centerboard box during roll tacks. Maybe I can have......

Words: 297 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Transcendece of Art in "Sailing to Byzantium"

...Magalí Ghione English Literature II April, 14th, 2014 The Transcendence of Art in W. B Yeats’ “Sailing to Byzantium” William Butler Yeats was an Irish poet, dramatist and author born in Dublin in 1865. As he lived during a period of political, economic and even social turmoil, his poetic style went through five periods that adapted to the current situation not only in Ireland, but all over Europe. Yeats’ special interest in the Celtic Revival Movement led him to become one of the founding members of the National Theatre of Ireland in 1904, which became the flagship for Irish playwrights and actors. In 1923 he was awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature “for his always inspired poetry, which in a highly artistic form gives expression to the spirit of a whole nation”. “Sailing to Byzantium,” written in 1926 and included in the collection The Tower, can be interpreted both as a journey taken by the speaker’s aged soul and as the process of transcendence of his own mortality by means of art. “Sailing to Byzantium,” consisting of a four eight-line stanza poem, is metered in iambic pentameter with two trios of alternating rhyme followed by a couplet. Having neither characters nor plot “Sailing to Byzantium” refers to the agony of old age and the work required to remain a vital individual. Byzantium is mainly a trading city: a center of power, knowledge and art, where “monuments of unageing intellect” (8) can be found. In the speaker’s view, Byzantium is “no country for old man”...

Words: 541 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Ship of Theseus

...the story of the ship of Theseus. In this story, a man named Theseus docked his ship and over time, he and the ship, grew old and weak. Over time, the ship started to fall apart and needed new parts until eventually all the original parts were replaced with new ones. This newly renovated ship is the first ship to consider. There is also a second ship that was reconstructed from all the original pieces of the old ship that had been set into a separate warehouse and put back together. We now have two ships: the renovated ship (created by replacing the old parts with new) and the reconstructed ship (created by reassembling the original pieces that had been removed). The question is: Which ship, the renovated or the reconstructed, is the original ship of Theseus? Whenever one makes an identity claim, such that two things are the same and share all the same properties, one usually uses two different descriptions to explain such phenomena. For example, "Mark Twain is Samuel Clemmons". Mark Twain is the author that most people know for writing The Adventure of Tom Sawyer, but this was his pen name, not his actual name; thus, making Mark Twain a descriptive name, but nevertheless having the same identity as Samuel Clemmons. Back to the ship of Theseus, the problem lies when trying to differentiate which ship is the original ship based on the principle of identity. Are the two ships the same as the original ship with only different descriptions? Is one the original ship while the......

Words: 644 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Ship Building

...Ship Building Industry of Bangladesh      The history of indigenous shipbuilding in Bangladesh goes back a long way. It is one of the early industries developed in Bengal based on its old business of building boats and sea vessels. Bangladesh has a strong background in building ships since ancient times. Many countries of Asia and Europe regularly bought ships built in Chittagong.       Bangladesh has a strong background in building ships since ancient times. It is quite natural in that Bangladesh has more than 200 rivers with a total length of about 22,155km plus a long coast line on the Bay of Bengal. It is little known today that Bangladesh was the center of building ocean-going vessels in Asia between the 15th and 17th century.        In the early 19th century, the shipyards of Chittagong built many commercial ships of up to 1,000 tons and also British navy vessels that participated in the battle of Trafalgar in 1805. Due to this historic prosperous background and also a natural geographical advantage, there are presently more than 200 shipbuilding and ship-repair yards in Bangladesh. | Ship Building Industry in Bangladesh | Prospect of Shipbuilding Industry in Bangladesh:       The history of indigenous shipbuilding in Bangladesh goes back a long way. It began with wooden-bodied passenger vessels having two decks and gradually improved to steel-body construction of multi-deck passenger carriers in the eighties as the passenger transportation in reverine......

Words: 1866 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Sunken Ship

...The Last Suffering Ship Reflection Dustin Teuton PHL/251 AUG 25, 2014 Robert DuBose The Last Suffering Ship Reflection The illness has taken its first life and people are starting to panic. By this point the crew has done all they can do to get the repairs done pushing them self to exhaustion. The nurses and helpers are tenting to all the patients and distributing the vaccine as fast as possible and to the right patients. I believe the way they are only giving half doses out and waiting to see who doesn’t show signs of getting better before giving the full dose is working and an affective way to calm more people down. I would try and isolate patients from non-sick passengers as much as possible to help prevent spread. For ship security most cruise lines or any kind of passenger ship should and would have a security team even if its trained crewmembers. They would also have a brig on board the ship for any type of crime that was committed, so in the case of the passengers who are starting to get edgy and wild trying to find the medication on there own and attacking crew members, I would have the security team deal with them in a manner that is stern but professional to show the rest of the passengers that in this case acting like a mad man and attacking crew to find the medication is going to land you a chance card straight to the brig. The captain should be updated by the doc every so often by a runner just to know what is going on with the illness. His......

Words: 795 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Mentor Ship

...arose and I have still not been paid. 2. What issues have you encountered since the last meeting and how did you address them? Several issues have come up at work since our last meeting. I am working with my mentor to establish a positive way of approaching my manager about my issues and how to deal with his response to my situation. 3. Interview your mentor to gather information about his or her organization, department, and job description. You will use this information in your Motivation Plan assignment, due in Week 5. How has he or she seen attitudes, emotions, personalities, and values influence the behavior of people in his or her department? We talked about how the attitude of the employee can greatly effect the productivity of the office. If an employee is extremely un-happy they will become less productive and could even cause other employee’s to become less productive. One employee could cause the entire office to have issues and not be able to stay on task. 4. Discuss how your mentor has applied principles of motivation and satisfaction while in a leadership role. How did these applied principles increase morale? Some principles that my mentor has used was using more prestigious positions to help boost moral, offer extended time off as a bonus for completing a project along with gym and various other clubs memberships as perks for jobs. I confirm that this session occurred to my......

Words: 461 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Solar Sailing

... How do we do this? How does man find a place to settle when the planet he has called home since the beginning of time is slowly, but surely, dying? The solution is in the history of man himself. The human population took millennia to grow out of Africa. Slowly, man crawled and then walked, eventually running to every corner of the planet. When water ways could not be crossed man settled. When the area he was in could no longer support his life or the life of those around him he moved on. Agriculture led to permanent settlements where people could raise crops year after year and populations could grow. Overpopulation and a lack of supplies or curiosity of the unknown could have led man to the first ocean going ships. Whatever it was the seas and ships lead to no one place on earth undiscovered. “Numerous oceanic islands were discovered, but every inhabitable land had already been reached and settled by one apparently homogeneous type of man,” Thor Heyerdahl wrote, “referred to in the early journals as ‘Indians,’ but later denominated the Polynesian sub-division of the yellow-brown race.” This quote coming from The Voyage of the Raft Kon-Tiki which Heyerdahl and others hand built and used to try and prove a scientific theory, that Polynesia was settled from the Americas not Asia. Heyerdahl was interested not necessarily how these people got there but where did they come from. Many scholars at the time agreed that they peoples of the Pacific Islands were......

Words: 1136 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

The Dutch Ships

...The Dutch Ships by Rai San’yo was a great piece of history. The main purpose of this poem is to shed light on the happenings of the time. This was not a formal history piece, as it was designed to be an informal piece that described the events that occurred in the early 1800’s. The purpose for this piece was simple, yet complex. The poems form was meant to show the feeling that the people had about these ships and the people on them. This is demonstrated by the line, from the Dutch Ships by Rai Sanyon, “The red-haired Westerners are coming!”(Line 6). This was arguably an attempt to give the reader insight to the worry that the Dutch was causing by simply visiting the island. This is due to the inherent fear of cultural contamination that the Japanese had experienced 100 years ago. This was also entering a transition time for Japan; clashes of people’s were happening. This line serves to tell us their opinions of them, which gave a negative connotation. The term “red-haired Westerner” could be comparable to the term “slant eye” when trying to define negative connotation. This tells of the time period of Japan, early 1800’s as we know. The style of this poem matches well with how it sounds. The sentences are noticeably emotional, with short ideas in them. His comments demonstrated a quick and sporadic view of all that was happening. This style adds very well with how the author felt. The poem is oppressive in nature; this is not about welcoming the Westerners. Line 4 of......

Words: 1691 - Pages: 7

Free Essay


...precautions to be taken between the ship and the terminal. Where any question is not considered to be applicable, a note to that effect should be inserted in the remarks column. See ISGOTT Guidelines for Completing the Ship/Shore Safety Check List for more detail descriptions behind each specific question in below matrix. The presence of YES/NO in the columns "ships" and "terminal" indicates that checks shall be carried out by the party concerned. The presence of the letters A, P and R in the column "code" indicates the following: A The mentioned procedures and agreements shall be in writing and signed by both parties. P In case of a negative answer, the operation shall not be carried out without the permission of the Port Authority. R Indicates items to be re-checked at intervals not exceeding that agreed in the declaration. Items marked R to be confirmed checked with sign/time each they are checked. PART A – Bulk Liquid General – Physical Checks |Bulk Liquid - General |Ship |Terminal |Code |Remarks | |1 There is safe access between the ship and shore | | |R | | |2 The ship is securely moored? | | |R | | |3 The agreed ship/shore communication......

Words: 1912 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Sailing to Byzantium Yeats portrays feelings towards death in ‘Sailing to Byzantium’. ! ! ‘Sailing to Byzantium’ shows Yeats in the latter years of his life as he is quickly approaching the certainty of death; Yeats is aware that he is ‘fastened to a dying animal’, and accepts the concept. Yeats writes the poem with four separate stanzas to portray the numerous thought patterns and ambiguity occurring in his mind towards death; these thought patterns occupy stages on his journey to the ‘holy city of Byzantium’. This contrasts with the airman in ‘An Irish Airman’, where Yeats’ singular stanza reflects the airman’s certainty and single arc of thought.! ! Yeats’ opening is blunt and directly to the point, showing an apparent lack of enthusiasm for his old age; Yeats appears worn down with age. The rhythm of the opening stanza is slow and steady, which portrays the Yeats, the ‘paltry thing’, has also slowed down due to his age. Yeats opens the poem with ‘that’, which shows a sense of disconnection from the scene he is describing, as he is no longer part of the world as previously known. The slow, trudging tone of the poem reflects Yeats’ largely negative feelings towards old age and the realisation of death. The tone is almost tedious, the very antithesis of ‘In Memory Of’, in which Yeats speaks of the beauty of youth with bright imagery, ‘light of evening, and glamorous clothing, ‘silk kimonos’. Both ‘In Memory Of’ and ‘Sailing to Byzantium’ include the mention of summer......

Words: 1121 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Ship Break

...Ship Breaking Industry of Bangladesh Presentation Speech Slide1: Today I am going to talk about the burning issue of Bangladesh…It’s all about the ship breaking industry. Slide 2: Here is an outline of my presentation. Slide 3: At first let me make you know about the definition of ship breaking....... ship breaking and recycling is defined as an industry that, through the use of land, infrastructure, machinery, and labor and through the consumption of utilities, converts ships that have outlived their economic life into steel and other recyclable items, which are then sold in local markets. Slide 4: Ship breaking was started in 1960 in UK & USA and in Bangladesh it was introduced commercially in 1990. Slide 5: We know Bangladesh is gifted with many natural gifts. It has the large sea shore which is the great advantage of ship breaking…besides this the socio economic condition of Bangladesh is a plus point to this site. Slide 6: It is the overall picture of ship recycling in the world where Bangladesh holds the 2nd position. Slide 7&8: Here is an aerial information about the ship breaking area which is growing faster. Slide 9: As a giant in the ship breaking world Bangladesh is getting benefits from this site both economically and socially. You will be glad to know that government is earning a revenue of 9000 million in BDT each year from this industry…it meets the demand of domestic steel about 80-90%.On the other hand it has created employment for......

Words: 691 - Pages: 3