Premium Essay

Points to Address in Precision Case Study

In: Business and Management

Submitted By kelly
Words 778
Pages 4
Precision Worldwide, Inc case study.

Begin by talking about the issues …..

Substantive Issues Raised.
The primary issue at hand involves the relevant cost of a set of replacement parts. The parts, however, range from those that are totally manufactured and ready for sale, to those that have not yet been manufactured but for which raw material is on hand, to those that have not yet been manufactured and for which no inventory of raw material exists. The case solution turns in large part on the use of contribution analysis. However, the concepts of sunk costs, opportunity costs, and product substitution are prominent aspects of any reasonable analysis.

The product in question, a steel ring, is used as a replacement part for industrial machines manufactured and sold by both Precision Worldwide, Inc and their competitors. It sells for $1,350 per hundred rings with annual sales of approximately 36,000 rings. One competitor, Henri Poulenc, has introduced a plastic ring. This ring lasts up to four times as long and is priced at about the same level as PWI’s product.

Mr. Thorborg, the gm of the German plant of PWI, must analyze the data, the conflicting views of his sales manager and his development engineer, and make a decision as to whether PWI should begin the manufacture of a plastic ring. In addition, a plan needs to be designed as to the pricing policy to follow for both the steel and the plastic rings. Finally, some consideration should be given to the effect of the decision upon the firm’s image in the marketplace.

Many of the issues involved in the suggested analysis of the case cluster around relevant costs and contribution analysis. The case illustrates several different layers of sophistication in terms of relevant cost analysis. Some ideas to review: address the concept of eliminating applied fixed overhead in a short run, relevant cost analysis…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

West Point Case Study

...West Point Case Analysis Bellevue University Description “A Cadet will not lie, cheat or steal nor tolerate those who do”, reads West Point’s honor code, allegedly violated in 1976. The West Point Cheating Incident revolves around an incident from 1976, where over 100 juniors were alleged to have cheated on an electrical engineering exam. Cheating on an exam can have damning ramifications at any school, but when it comes to West Point; it is a direct violation of the schools highly held honor code. The honor code is a West Point tradition, and has helped mold military leaders with high integrity and strong values. Due to the sheer number of individuals, who were alleged to be involved, and where the scandal was happening, the event garnered national attention. Due to the uproar in the press and across the country, more pressure was placed on General Sidney Berry, Superintendent of the United States Naval Academy by bureaucrats and politicians alike. Diagnosis West Point is not your ordinary school setting. It is a breeding ground for training our nation’s best and brightest future military leaders. In the United States Military, it is imperative for soldiers to lead with character, while remaining calm under fire. It seems West Point, at the time of this event, concerned itself more around punishing for crimes than it did developing character. If West Point was truly interested in developing leaders with high character, it would not utterly dismiss......

Words: 801 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Precision World Wide Case Study

...Precision Worldwide Inc. manufactures steel rings, which are used in certain machines. French firm Henri Poulenc competitor of Precision Worldwide Inc is introducing a plastic ring, which is a substitute for the steel retaining rings. Hans Thorborg, general manager of Precision Worldwide Inc. is worried because the plastic rings not only have a longer life than the steel rings but are also manufactured at a lower price. PWI has a large quantity of steel rings and substantial inventory of special steel. In a meeting, the general manager, the sales manager, the accountant and the development engineer discussed the possible problems and alternatives for this problem. For PWI, manufacturing plastic rings was defiantly the best solution for the problem but they still wondered what they would do with the inventory they had. According to the sales manager, customers new about the new plastic rings and were asking if PWI was already selling them. The development engineer calculated that the plastic rings could be by mid-September. The sales manager thought that since the plastic rings could be produced at a really low cost, the inventory problem was irrelevant. He suggested that if the steel rings couldn’t be sold they should just throw them away. Another problem was that Henri Poulenc was selling the plastic rings at the same price that PWI was selling the steel rings. Not manufacturing the plastic rings would be like ignore a considerable profit margin. In the meeting they......

Words: 666 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

A Case Study on the Difficulties Faced by Tm Point Kuala Selangor in Operating It Shop

...A CASE STUDY ON THE DIFFICULTIES FACED BY TM POINT KUALA SELANGOR IN OPERATING IT SHOP BACHELOR OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION WITH (HONS) OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT FACULTY OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT NOVEMBER 2009 AbstrAct ABSTRACT This case study will be conducted in TMpoint Kuala Selangor. I would like to identify the difficulties faced by this organization in operating it shop. As this company is a serviceoriented organization, they need to satisfy customer’s needs and wants. Sometimes, they fail to achieve due to some problems or lacking. In this case, I will use the customer’s data of fixed-line termination and monthly statistical data on customer complain to explore the symptoms of low customer satisfaction. I also will conduct some observations in order to gather relevant data. The computer software package which is Statistical Package for Social Science (SPSS student Version 14.0 for Window) will be used to analyze the data that have been gathered, furthermore to identify the major problems faced by this organization. There are some symptoms that has been identified; there are increasing number of customer complain, fixed-line termination, not well-educating the customers and shortage of worker. When the problem has been identified, conclusion and recommendations will suggested to the organization in order to be the best service provider in the world. They need to take corrective action if they want to ensure company’s survilvalness. vii TABLE OF CONTENT...

Words: 13705 - Pages: 55

Premium Essay

Precision Worldwide, Inc. Case Study

...Precision Worldwide, Inc. Case Study Involved Parties: Competitor-French Firm: Henri Poulenc Precision Worlwide, Inc.-German Firm Hans Thorborg-General Manager Gerhard Henk-Sales Manager Bodo Eisenbach- Development Engineer Patrick Corrigan-Parent Company Spokesman Background: Precision Worldwide, Inc. (PWI) manufactures industrial machines and equipment for sale in numerous countries. Repair and replacement parts account for a substantial part of the company’s business. The replacement part in question, steel rings, occur in the machines manufactured only in PWI’s Frankfurt Germany plant, but can also be used on some competitor’s machines. The steel ring manufactured by PWI has an average normal life of about 2 months. Machines require between 2 and 6 rings to operate. Individual rings are replaced as they wear out. Over the years, competition had increased and now a competitor company, the French firm Henri Poulenc, has entered the market with a superior plastic ring that replaces the steel ring. The plastic ring is less costly to manufacture and has a longer life. Situation: The PWI sales manager, Gerhard Henk, is asking when this product will be available for him to sell that his competitor already has on the market, particularly in France where the competitor is the strongest. Bodo Eisenbach, the PWI development Engineer, estimates the plastic rings can be produced in about 4 months at a tool and equipment cost of about $7,500. PWI currently has about $390...

Words: 1027 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Case Study

...Section 5 School Examples, Student Case Studies, and Research Examples • School Examples, page 5.3 – School-Wide Screening, page 5.4 – Progress Monitoring, page 5.5 – Tiered Service Delivery, page 5.9 – Data-Based Decision Making, page 5.13 – Parent Involvement, page 5.16 – Resources, page 5.22 August 2006 Overview In November 2002, the United States Department of Education requested that the National Research Center on Learning Disabilities (NRCLD) identify, describe, and evaluate the implementation of responsiveness to intervention (RTI) in elementary schools throughout the United States. The NRCLD staff worked with the six Regional Resource Centers (RRCs) to identify potential sites and solicit school participation. More than 60 schools across the country initially were considered, and information from 41 of those schools was submitted. The NRCLD research staff reviewed the extensive amount of information submitted and judged that 19 of those schools were engaging in one or more commendable RTI practices based on a review of the following six components of an RTI service-delivery model: • School-wide screening. Screening is a type of assessment characterized by quick, low cost, repeatable testing of critical academic skills or behaviors and can be administered by individuals with minimal amounts of training. A screening measures whether a student should be judged at risk. If a student meets the criteria for at-risk status, he or she is considered for more......

Words: 15342 - Pages: 62

Premium Essay

Paulson Precision Case

...PAULSON PRECISION PRODUCTS, INC. TEAM 10 - P2F10 1.a. What price should PPP charge for its pads? • $1300 for Colerick Foundation Company – First purchase. • $1400 for distributors. [pic] 1.b. Explain the reasons for the recommended price. As it is shown on the table above, the economic value for the tests involving 11 ½" pads ranged from $1400 to $1900, which represents the maximum a customer would pay in either case. Because there is not enough data to adequately determine whether the true value for an 11 ½" pad is $1400 or $1900, we should select the lower of the two as the maximum price. Therefore, the upper price limit for PPP's curled metal pad is $1400. On the other hand, if PPP decides to price their product based only on material costs of the existing product, the price would be closer to $167 (6 CMI pads used, $1000 worth of asbestos pads). This results in a pricing range of $167 to $1400, with the lower price recovering fixed costs and a small profit. In choosing the optimal price, PPP should take advantage of the performance and operational benefits that its product offers. Not only are the pads more efficient and last longer, they are easier to handle, reaching temperature that are almost three times less then those of wooden pads. There was significant savings gained by using PPP pads in both tests, ranging from 29 to 35%. Customers should be willing to pay for these benefits, especially when presented to them in terms of their......

Words: 1115 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Case Study of Precision Technology

...Manage Performance Management Systems Assessment 1: Case Study of Precision Technology Case Questions 1. What is the primary goal Performance Management System (PMS)? The primary goal PMS is to develop a PMS that drives the performance of the company to achieve its objectives and strategies throughout identification, evaluation and development of the job performance. The aim of a performance management system is to help employees reach their full potential for the benefit of both the employee and the organisation. Having a clear understanding of job expectations, responsibilities, required competencies, regular feedback and the expected behaviours does this. The employee may feel that they are carrying out their duties for which they are employed, although those above that employee may not think the individual is carrying out those duties satisfactorily. However if nobody informs the employee of the situation, there is no chance of improvement so the management performance system gives a chance of communication. A performance management meeting organised to discuss the employee performance should be a two way communication at which the employee should be aware: • Know the performance goals that they need to achieve as well as the expected behaviour wanted by the organisation. • An agreed plan of action for the areas of improvement, with a guidelines on how the goals will be measured • Organise of training if needed or wanted by employee ...

Words: 2595 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Precision Worldwide, Inc. Case Study

...Precision Worldwide, Inc. Case Study BUS5431 – Managerial Accounting Summary Precision Worldwide, Inc. (PWI) manufactures industrial equipment and parts for sale in numerous countries. Repair and replacement parts account for a substantial part of the company’s business with the replacement part in question, steel rings, occur in the machines manufactured only in PWI’s German plant, but can also be used on some competitor’s machines. This steel ring has an average normal life of about 2 months. These individual rings are replaced as they wear out and recently competition has increased and now a competitor has entered the market with a superior and less expensive plastic ring that can replace the steel ring. The general manager of the German plant, Hans Thorborg has been considering the introduction of a similar plastic rings as a substitute for the steel rings. There is a lot of potential for this product in this market because there is a lower manufacturing cost and a greater durability compare to steel rings. The company is wondering if it is worth to shift from steel rings to plastic rings, but there are a lot of facts that they need to consider. There has been conflicting views concerning the future of the steel rings departments if they should change to plastic rings in order to acquire competitive advantage in this market and what will they do with the special steel after they have implemented the new product. A decision must be made as whether to start......

Words: 1749 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Case Study- West Point

...Description: Lt. General Sidney Berry, Superintendent of the United States Military Academy at West Point has been faced with a series of difficult decisions after being notified of underclassmen at the campus where caught cheating, a violation of the Cadet Honor Code with the Academy. All cadets that are found guilty by the Honor System are subject to expulsion. The decisions Berry is faced with raises issues concerning ethics, organizational adjustment and change, and action planning to tackle the arising conflict. Through acting in the best wishes of West Point’s standards, Lt. General Berry must also heavily consider the interests of the Department of the Army, Congress, West Point alumni, current cadets on campus, and the public with the gaining acknowledgement of the incident. Diagnosis: Throughout the incident, questions arised in a variety of avenues regarding West Point’s standards and the possibility of misalignment of the discipline displayed versus the objectives of the Academy. Questions such as whether the Honor Code was to general to the extent of not being able to evenly and fairly enforce conduct or whether constitutional guarantees of due process were considered during the adjudication of disputes arising under the Honor Code. This incident could also be simply a result of cadets pushing the limits of the Academy of what they are and aren’t able to get away with; much like a child is with his or her parental figures. Nevertheless, the integrity of......

Words: 585 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Precision Worlwide Case

...Managerial Accounting Week 2 Group Discussion Week 2: Group Work- Harvard Business Case 1 Group Members: Michael Fant, Jennifer Meyering, Christopher Presley, James Ramson, Jacinta Stockton, Alistair Winfield, Judy Zeitang What action should Hans Thorborg take? Why? Our analysis of this case is to advise Hans Thorborg to move to producing the plastic rings. It is important for PWI to evolve with the industry, and refusing to transition to the new product could have a devastating impact on their future sales. Although PWI has a strong presence in the market, it’s stated in the case study that the plastic rings have at least four times the wearing properties of the steel rings. Therefore, while the steel ring currently lasts for an estimated two months, the plastic ring will last for an estimated eight months. Buying a plastic ring would guarantee a customer a better quality product and essentially a better bang for their buck. Also, the total costs to produce the plastic ring would be significantly less allowing the company to take advantage of a huge profit margin. Instead of trying to justify the stock on hand and how much he paid for the stock, he should avoid the sunk cost fallacy. There is not enough information in the study to compare production costs, but with the information available it seems that the plastic rings would be more profitable for the company. As for the stock that is already on hand, there is opportunity to sell them to locations where the......

Words: 987 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Precision Worldwide, Inc Case

... Assignment #2 Precision Worldwide, Inc Summary Precision worldwide Inc is currently in the dilemma of determining how to go about the introduction of a new French and Japanese prototype of their steel ring. The French were able to reinvent this plastic ring at a lower cost and more durable at the same time. This is extremely detrimental to the steel ring market and will force precision worldwide out of business if actions are not taken. Related Business Issues 1. Excessive inventory levels of steel rings Hans thorborg carries large quantity of steels rings and special steels inventory, which values about $390,000. The special steels couldn’t even sale as scrap as it described in article. The article also indicates that hans thorborg will cost $110,900 to convert special steels into 34500 steels rings. Hans thorborg needs to take in to account the sunk cost of the steel ring and how to be effective with the production of the plastic ring. The sunk cost fallacy is that sunk costs are sunk whatever your decision is and only the future matters. The fallacy in thinking about the sunk costs is precisely that people feel completed to get their moneys work even if it makes them suffer Whether or not the steel rings sell. The second aspect that will influence han`s decision is the will still have over 15000 units when the date of plastic rings roll out. 2. Cost of Steel Rings and Manufacturing Facilities The total cost of 100 steel rings is $1107.90, which is about 3......

Words: 807 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Case-in-Point Analysis

...Case-In-Point Analysis Marine algae and krill are very important to the environment in the Antarctic. Raven, P., Berg, L., and Hassenzahl, D. (2010) presents the case study “How Humans Have Affected the Antarctic Food Web” to examine the problem. The purpose of this paper is to identify any unintended consequences of humankind’s activities that have led to environmental problems, describe how scientific or technological activities are exacerbating or improving the existing situation, discuss how a proper application of the scientific method could have helped the problem, and address any alternative solution beyond the scientific method. Unintended consequences There are multiple human activities that have led to environmental problems. The first is the thinning of the ozone layer. This is the cause of man-made compounds, such as halocarbons. The Global Climate Change and Ozone Layer Protection (2005) website states “Halocarbons are formed when halogen gases such as fluorine, chlorine and bromine become attached to carbon. The smaller halocarbons turn into a gas quite easily and are the prime suspects in ozone depletion (What causes Ozone Layer Depletion?, para. 2). The depletion to the ozone layer leads to a global climate change. Raven, P., Berg, L., and Hassenzahl, D. (2010) explain: “As the water has warmed in recent decades around Antarctica, less pack ice has formed during winter months. Large numbers of marine algae are found in and around the pack ice, providing a...

Words: 900 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Case in Point

...CASE STUDY: HOW HUMANS HAVE AFFECTED THE ANTARCTIC FOOD WEB Although the icy waters around Antarctica may seem an inhospitable environment, a complex food web is found there. The base of the food web consists of microscopic, photosynthetic algae present in vast numbers in the well-lit, nutrient-rich water. A huge population of herbivores—tiny shrimp like krill—eat these marine algae. Krill, in turn, support a variety of larger animals. A major consumer of krill is the baleen whale, which filters krill out of the frigid water. Baleen whales include blue whales, humpback whales, and right whales. Squid and fishes also consume krill in great quantities. These, in turn, are eaten by other carnivores: toothed whales such as the sperm whale, elephant seals and leopard seals, king penguins and emperor penguins, and birds such as the albatross and the petrel. Humans have had an impact on the Antarctic food web as they have had on most other ecosystems. Before the advent of whaling, baleen whales consumed huge quantities of krill. Until a global ban on hunting large whales was enacted in 1986, whaling steadily reduced the number of large baleen whales in Antarctic waters. As a result, of fewer whales eating krill, more krill became available for other krill-eating animals, whose populations increased. Now that commercial whaling is regulated, it is hoped that the number of large baleen whales will slowly increase, and that appears to be the case for some species. However, the......

Words: 638 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Case in Point

...different current levels of climate change. There is no scientific method that could have avoided Hurricane Katrina. Scientific research state that more extreme weather changes the forms of rainfall and drought can have an expressive impact on the environment. The proximity of Southern Louisiana and New Orleans, shelves the Gulf of Mexico that is a highly vulnerable area for storm surges and hurricane. The Mississippi River, Lake Borgne, and Lake Pontchartrain rise and always overflow during flood and hurricane. Hurricanes are natural disasters unprecedented for America. The fury of Mother Nature cannot be stopped; the tragedy of killer storm Katrina left devastating effects that was preventable. If society ever reaches a technological point where they can influence hurricanes and alternative solution can be implemented. The weakening of hurricanes would be advisable to control the environment over the upcoming decades. If this method works, as hurricane approach landfall then the flow of water flow would be cut off before it hit upstream. Changing the direction of flooding would be detoured to water where no human life inhabits. Louisiana sits below sea level where levees are erected to control flooding this issue proves to be fertile because this city is threatened every time the skies turn gray. New Orleans is built on unconsolidated sediment where there is no rock underneath this area, in other words the city sits on an area that has no good foundation. Another......

Words: 668 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Case in Point

...Case-In-Point In this global economy, energy is an important factor to stay competitive in the world. Solar energy, wind power, water sources, and fossil fuels are available these days. Human beings need to subdue the universe and transform these sources for a better life. The Arctic National Wildlife Refuge is a sleeping reserve of fossil fuels. The Yucca Mountain is storage for nuclear waste. The Three Gorges Dam in China is the biggest sources of hydroelectricity in the world. How viable is each of sources of energy? Is the exploitation indefinite? What is the environmental impact in the ecosystem? Which one of the sources is the best based on ethical and economical issues? The Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR) is a fossil fuel and natural gas energy source located in Alaska, USA. The fossil fuels reserve is very abundant. According to the US geological survey, on a 1980 research, ANWR has 17 billions of barrels of oils and 34 trillions of Natural Gas. The environmental impact, if it exists, is minimum; only 8% of the refuge will be used, and the maximum footprint development allowed by Congress is about 2000 acres. The new technology implemented at Prudhoe Bay has made the area more environmental friendly for wildlife. In order to protect the tundra, drill sites are constructed on 4' thick gravel pads. Even if a 1" drop of crude oil drips onto the pad, workers are required to shovel it up for proper disposal. (Prudhoe Bay,......

Words: 1193 - Pages: 5