Premium Essay

Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making Matrix

In: Business and Management

Submitted By akmommy18
Words 1008
Pages 5
Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making Matrix

Determine the ethical course of action for the following three scenarios from the perspective of each of the three philosophical approaches: consequentialism, deontology, and virtue ethics. Then, complete the matrix below by writing a few sentences stating the ethical course of action and the reasoning from that approach’s perspective. Clearly differentiate the reasons for each of the three approaches. Keep in mind that, although rationale might differ, the ethical course of action for a given scenario might be the same for each philosophical approach. Be sure to state the ethical course of action as well as the rationale behind it, according to the philosophical approach.

Scenario 1

The mayor of a small seaside town faces a tough decision. A prominent developer has submitted a proposal to build a large mall and resort in the town. This development is estimated to bring $150 million in tourism each year and several hundred new jobs to the community, which badly needs the economic boost. The proposed location of the new development, however, is a site that now houses the only nursing home and senior citizens’ recreation center in the area. Both the nursing home and recreation center would have to be demolished, affecting 100 seniors and 30 employees. There is no other location in town where the new development can be built. How should the mayor decide: in favor of economic prosperity or in defense of his elderly citizens?

Scenario 2

Catalina works for a regional sales branch of a large pharmaceutical company. Individual employees as well as the entire branch receive incentive packages if they reach certain sales goals. If a sales rep meets his or her individual goals, he or she receives a large bonus check at the end of the year. Likewise, if all the sales reps meet their goals, the entire…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Approaches to Decision Making

...Approaches to Decision Making Paper Satara McDade HCA/250 7/26/12 Catherine Doughty Introduction Managers not only have to supervise as well they have to make smart decisions when it comes to problems or issues in general in order to keep his or her department running smoothly. There are many different decision making approaches, but in this particular assignment only two will be discussed and they are rational and bounded rationality. When making decisions that will affect others, it is important to use the right approach as well as come to a decision that will take care of the problem or solve the issue. This paper will also discuss how a group of nursing home administrators and an infection control officer has come across an increasing rate of infection at a nursing home. The nursing home is at risk for fines if it continues to have this problem and the administrators need to come up with a way to handle this problem. Decision-Making With this particular situation, the administrators need to be aware of how any changes will affect the patients as well as the employees. Many managers’ decision making will be rational, meaning that they will make logical and consistent choices to maximize value (Robbins, Decenzo, and Coulter 2011). While the majority of managers already have their own process to make decisions, so do not and they face many problems due to lack of knowledge in reference to decision making. Rational decision making will lead to......

Words: 609 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Evaluating Philosophical Approaches for Ethical Decision Making

...Running Head: EVALUATING PHILOSOPHICAL APPOACHES FOR ETHICAL DECISION MAKING Evaluating Philosophical Approaches for Ethical Decision Making Wayne Lambeth ACC 260 Donna Adams November 4, 2012 My classmates as well as I were required to evaluate philosophical methods that were used in Appendix B. Evaluating these methods would consist of whether or not a course of action that was taken made sense. I will discuss the philosophical approaches and determine whether or not that the course of action were ethical decisions and was it the best decision for the correct reasons in addition to determining the reasons are ethical. There are three key factors to evaluating philosophical approaches and they consist of consequentialism, deontology, and virtue ethics. Consequentialism is the theory of the value especially the moral value that would be judged by its consequences. Deontology is slightly different due to focusing on moral responsibility as well as the obligation of motivating the decisions that are made or the actions of the consequence. Virtue ethics has to deal with moral within a community as well as the integrity of an individual. The following scenarios has an ethics dilemma that be addressed. Scenario 1 The mayor is faced with building a new development that will create new jobs and economic stability to a community that really needs it and the dilemma is that it has to be built where the community center for the elderly is located and......

Words: 942 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Approaches to Decision Making

...Approaches to Decision Making Desiree Bennett HCA/250 2/9/2013 Wakita Bradford I choose scenario number 2 to write about which involves a nursing home. This case incorporates a number of nursing home managers, including an infection control official. There has been a rise of contamination rates in the nursing home. It is very important to maintain the contamination rates as low as possible; one reason is with higher rates may cause the patients to have more health problems. If the nursing home continues to have higher contamination rates they might also get penalties. The nursing home managers are likely to talk about possible decisions in a conference to decrease contamination in the center. There are several making decisions methods the administrators may use to come to a decision in connection with this case which was provided. A non-programmed decision would be required in this case since it needs a customized solution. Though, any security rules together with any plans which the nursing home has ought to be followed. Administration in the nursing home must incorporate a few decisions like scheduling, arranging, leading, and managing. One more method might be to use a systematic method in this case. There are several reasons that group making decisions is much better in many instances compared to one which is made by one person. Group decisions may provide the required input/ information to assist generates more options to have the correct decision. In...

Words: 666 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Individual: Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making

...Week 4 Individual Paper Angela Tai ACC 260 May 10, 2013 Douglas Kildsig Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making Three philosophical approaches are taken when ethical decisions are being made. These approaches include consequentialism, deontology, and virtue ethics. Consequentialism focus on the consequences associated with the decision that was made. When an individual uses this approach, that individual should ensure that they are fully knowledgeable of the problem in order to make an ethical decision. It is crucial that the person has the ability to examine the affects both negative and positive that will occur because of the decision. When using the deontology approach, one focuses on if it was a right decision or not instead of focusing on the consequences. With this method, all of the questions about ethics and principles arise. The last method is called the virtue ethic approach. This method strives on keeping the morals and integrity of both the community and the individuals. By keeping the morals and integrity of a community when making decisions, it ensures that the decision will be made using the personality traits of the individual. These traits include honest, generosity, wisdom, intuition, and common sense. Is the course of action really the most ethical choice? Scenario One The mayor made the most ethical choice by refusing the proposal and scarifying the development of hundred jobs and million dollars to be able to......

Words: 1097 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Approaches to Decision Making Paper

...Approaches to Decision Making Paper xxxxxxxx May 12, 2013 HCA/250 xxxxxxxxxx Approaches to Decision Making Paper A health care organization is experiencing increased costs for staffing and overhead. Management must determine how to reduce costs without compromising patient care and safety. This paper will explore rational decision-making and bounded rationality, two decision-making approaches that the health care organization can use for determining how to reduce costs. This paper will also explain why making a group decision is better than a decision by an individual, as well as list the advantages and disadvantages of group decision-making. According to Robbins, DeCenzo, and Coulter there are three decision-making approaches. These three approaches are rational decision-making, bounded rationality, and intuitive decision-making. In order for management of the health care organization to determine how to reduce costs they can use rationality or bounded rationality. Making a rational decision requires complete knowledge of the problem, all possible solutions, and the consequences of each solution. The decision maker must use logic and objectivity to determine which solution option will achieve the company’s goal. Rational decision-making will be challenging for the managers because it is unrealistic to analyze every detail of each solution option and the associated risks of each. Using bounded rationality......

Words: 670 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Parameters of Ethical Decision Making

...Ethical decision making is an essential aspect in understanding and demonstrating the values of an organization. The intense pressures of business may not always allow time for reflection, and the high stakes may tempt us to compromise our ideals. Many of us already have well-developed ethical outlooks but by considering various approaches to ethical decision making, we are better equipped to make the right choices when the need arises. Joseph Weiss (2009) identifies fundamental ethical principles that guide decision making: utilitarianism, universalism, rights, justice, and ethical virtue. John Rawls contributes his Theory of Justice as Fairness as another approach for consideration in resolving ethical dilemmas. Utilitarianism The utilitarian view states that an action is considered right or good based on its consequences (2009). The utilitarian approach tries both to increase the good done and to reduce the harm done. An ethical corporate action is the one that produces the greatest good and does the least harm for all who are affected, including customers, employees, shareholders, the community, and the environment. Universalism The universalistic approach holds that moral authority is determined by the extent to which the intention of an act treats all persons with respect (2009). Respect and compassion for all others are a requirement of this reasoning. This approach also calls attention to the common conditions that are important to the welfare of everyone: a......

Words: 1332 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Ethical Decision Making

...Ethical Decision Making  Ethics are principles that define behavior as fair and proper and they are concerned with how a moral person should behave when it comes to making an ethical decision (Josephson Institute of Ethics, 2002). Evaluating and deciding among competing options is often key in making a fair choice since principles do not always dictate a single "moral" course of action.  The decision of whether to lay off workers to enhance profits or to cut corners on quality to meet a deadline are examples of some choices regarding ethics business owners may face (Poznak Law Firm, 2003). The use of extremely low-wage foreign workers, like in the Nike organization case, is a current concern and the subject is a complex one.  There are many valid differences of opinion regarding what constitutes ethical behavior and how ethical decisions should be made and the subject is a complex one (Poznak Law Firm, 2003). There are always pros and cons involved with any choice and the decision itself can be quite time consuming. When it comes to deciding whether or not to use cheap labor to cut costs, businesses must examine the ethics behind their decision-making processes.  Four approaches that business owners commonly use to analyze ethical dilemmas are the utilitarian approach, which focuses on taking the action that will result in the greatest good for the greatest number of people; the moral rights approach, which is concerned with moral principles, regardless of the......

Words: 1178 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Approaches to Decision Making Theory

...Laroche  being  prescriptive  and  descriptive   Laroche follows a prescriptive method in arguing for decision making theory. He argues it is a social representation which will improve decision making. In his abstract he writes “The paper argues that […] the concept of organizational action should not be opposed to decision and decision-making. Decision and decisionmaking are best understood as social representations […]. As organization members think and act in terms of decision-making, a theory of organizational action cannot simply do without a theory of decision-making. “ showing clearly that he is prescribing a certain way of looking upon decision-making. This is further strengthened in the conclusion where he for example writes “This paper argued that decision-making is best understood as a process of reality creation through organization members’ representations of their own role and activity.” The extent to which Laroche is prescriptive is debatable however. He acknowledges descriptive factors such as when he claims in conclusion that “no theory of action can develop without integrating the fact that, to a significant extent, organizational members think and act in terms of decision-making... a relevant phenomenon for a theory of action, not a marginal one”. He lists examples from empirical studies in describing the decision-making process: “bureaucratic processes (e.g., Cyert and March 1963, Carter 1971), political processes (e.g.. Bower 1970),......

Words: 1091 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Approaches to Decision Making

...Approaches to Decision Making Cheryl Tyler 11/16/14 HCA 250 Melodie Griffin I chose scenario 2 as a subject of my paper. The nursing home needs to follow a certain protocol when it comes to cleaning. Nursing homes need to keep a low infection rate because of the fact that elderly individuals have a low immune system and may not bounce back as quickly after getting sick. It is important that not only the patients but the facility are taking care of. In this scenario the nursing administrators are having a meeting to discuss ways to reduce infection within the facility. This is the best possible way to come to a solution since they have been having a higher infection rate lately. The first thing to do is find out why and how the infection is spreading as well as to how fast it is spreading. This step is needed in order to find the cause or host of the problem in order to control the issue. The administrators will have to determine a budget of cost also. Infectious control can be costly so determining how much money they are spending on it is a must in order to stay in budget. Infections spread for many reasons and in many ways. If the patients are not getting the proper care then infections can spread. Which is why the administrators will have to make sure that all employees are doing their jobs both with patient care and housekeeping. Administrators need to ensure that all patients are getting the best quality of care. In order to do this employees need to be screened...

Words: 610 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Acc 260 Week 4 Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making

...ACC 260 Week 4 Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making Get Tutorial by Clicking on the link below or Copy Paste Link in Your Browser http://hwguiders.com/downloads/acc-260-week-4-critiquing-philosophical-approaches-to-ethical-decision-making/ For More Courses and Exams use this form ( http://hwguiders.com/contact-us/ ) Feel Free to Search your Class through Our Product Categories or From Our Search Bar (http://hwguiders.com/ ) As a student we are required to evaluate the philosophical approaches for each scenario from Appendix B. Evaluating whether or not the reasoning for the course of action listed makes sense. While working on the evaluation of the philosophical approaches we will discuss if the course of action is the most ethical, the best reasons for making the choices, and the reasons for believing this alternative is ethical. Consequentialism is the intent to maximize the usefulness of a decision. For this the relevance of this act depends on its consequences. For this approach it is essential to have a good ethical decisions and perception of it. With this it is important for students to analyze a decision in how the harmful and/or the benefits. This many philosophers’ debate ht consequences should count Deontology is different because it focuses on the obligation or duty in motivating the decision or the actions of the consequences. This depends on the respect, rights, and fairness. This approach brings up issues related......

Words: 6500 - Pages: 26

Premium Essay

Deontological and Teleological Approaches to Ethical Decision Making’

...‘Deontological and teleological approaches to ethical decision making’ The term deontological is an approach to Ethics that focuses on the rightness or wrongness of actions themselves, as opposed to the rightness or wrongness of the consequences of those or to the character and habits of the person, whilst on the other hand, teleological Teleology is a reason or explanation for something in function of its end, purpose, or goal. For example, a teleological explanation is where is does not focus on the action but it only focuses on the outcome or consequences. Ethical decision making helps people make difficult choices when faced with an ethical dilemma, a situation in which there is no clear right or wrong answer, Refers to the process of evaluating and choosing among alternatives in a manner consistent with ethical principles. In making ethical decisions, it is necessary to perceive and eliminate unethical options and select the best ethical. If an ethical approach if deontological, it means the morality of an action is intrinsic, which means that the act is completely wrong or completely right. Also the right or wrong of the act cannot change, it stays the same. For example - murder is wrong because it is wrong, it will always be wrong. Therefore this is a Deontological approach towards murder. On the other hand, if an ethical approach is Teleological, it means that it only focuses on the outcome that is caused by the action, also it is the result of an action that......

Words: 609 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Ethical Decision Making Paper

...Running Head: ETHICAL DECISION MAKING Ethical Decision Making Trishawna Y. Fleming EDCU 501 May 9, 2016 Liberty University Abstract This paper investigates the moral issue of an authorized proficient advocate who is rehearsing out of a congregation setting. The vast majority of the advocates' customers are customers who are general steady and well working. Because of the status of the client he sees he doesn't feel that it is important to keep records of the client. He sees subsequently he doesn't keep any records by any stretch of the imagination. He feels that in an alternate circumstance where his customers were not steady he would then need to consider record keeping. The accompanying clarifies why it is critical for every expert advisor to keep records in spite of the setting or state of the customers. I will likewise utilize the ACA's Decision Making Model to examine the circumstance and settle on the most ideal decisions and pick the best strategy for the guide to take keeping in mind the end goal to guarantee that he is rehearsing in a moral way. Ethical Dilemma 3 It is the obligation of every expert guide, morally, lawfully, professionally and clinically, to keep exact records relating to their customers. Professional counselors must keep records of clients with data relating to the evaluation and treatment of the client. Ethical dilemma 3 expresses that Dan is an expert advocate who feels that record keeping is a bit much since he works in with...

Words: 1483 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Ethical Decision Making

...review.................12 2.2.1 Objectivistic leadership research.................................................................14 Trait studies..................................................................................................14 Behaviour approach .....................................................................................20 Situational approach.....................................................................................21 Power-influence approach............................................................................24 Integrative approaches..................................................................................28 2.2.2 Constructivist-interpretative studies on leadership......................................39 2.2.3 Critical studies on leadership.......................................................................51 2.2.4 Postmodern approaches to leadership..........................................................56 2.3 The current state of leadership research and research on leadership in small enterprises……..............................................................................….....59 3 Researching leadership as a contextual phenomenon ............................................65 3.1 Underlying presuppositions...................................................................................65 3.2 Research task and strategy and methodological choices.......................................66 3.2...

Words: 100514 - Pages: 403

Premium Essay

Ethical Decision Making

...Approaches to ethical decision making at times can be made using different philosophical approaches, which was the first part of our assignment this week; the completion of Appendix B where we were to decide which course of action was to be taken based on each philosophical approach for the given scenarios. The three philosophical approaches are: consequentialism, deontology, and virtue ethics. Consequentialism is the view that the value of actions is derived solely from the value of its consequences. In accounting, this approach is used to analyze which decision is most ethical based on the harms and benefits to the stakeholders; basically, it is the decision that does the greatest good for the greatest amount of people. In short, consequentialism is the decision is ethical if the positive outcome is greater than the negative outcome. Deontology is the ethical theory that is concerned with duties and rights. Whereas consequentialism is concerned with actions consequences, deontology is concerned with the obligation or duty motivating the decision (Brooks, 2007, p. 330). Decisions are based around moral standards, rights, fairness, and principles. Virtue ethics seems to lie somewhere between consequentialism and deontology; its primary concern is with traits of character that are morally right. Virtue ethics focuses on an individual’s integrity and character in relation to the moral community, such as professional communities (Brooks, 2007, p. 332). Scenario......

Words: 1045 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Business Ethical Decision Making

...Introduction Ethical behavior is generally expected to be conducted within a business by its managers and employees. When business ethics is spoken by business people of it usually means one of three things (1) avoid breaking the criminal law in one’s work-related activity; (2) avoid action that may result in civil law suits against the company; (3) avoid actions that are bad for the company image (Erwin 2011). . Ethical issues in business will occur but can be solved and avoided in many cases that can help a company continue to be successful. Using an ethical decision making process will guide companies and its employees in the right direction to success and respect within the communities they serve. Most people involved in business whether functioning as a small business owner, employee, or chief executive officer of a multination company eventually face ethical or moral dilemmas in the workplace. Such dilemmas are usually complex, for they force the person making the decision to weigh the benefits that various business decisions impart on individuals including him or herself and groups with the negative repercussion that those same decisions usually have on other individuals or groups. What is Ethics? Business ethics is a subject that can be difficult to define. Any discussion of business ethics is a subjective one, for everyone brings different concepts of ethical behavior to the table. These moral standards are shaped by all sorts of things, from home environment......

Words: 2343 - Pages: 10