Premium Essay

Management- Employee Resistance

In: Business and Management

Submitted By lartz
Words 2682
Pages 11
Conflict at work stems from employees’ petty, childlike behaviour and their inability to understand the necessary decisions that manager’s make for the good of the whole organization. Critically discuss this statement, drawing upon course readings that engage with the issue of employee resistance.

Introduction

In the following essay I am going to argue that conflict at work stems from managers decisions to control and dominate the lives of its employees, as it misuses the power relationship in an attempt to enhance its control. I will discuss the article by (Prasad and Prasad 2000), (Clegg, Kornberger and Pitsis 2008) and (Knights and Roberts 1982) to demonstrate this point. I also argue that conflict stems from attempts by employees to counteract the domination of basic human qualities such as feelings and emotions as they act in an attempt to restore dignity within their lives. I will do this with reference to texts by (Cohen and Taylor 1992), (Prasad and Prasad 2000), (Knights and Collinson 1987) and (Roberts 1984). As organisations are clearly places of domination I argue the importance of conflict within society to inhibit organisations exploiting and manipulating its employees and society at large. For this argument I will use texts by (Morgan 2006), (Baken 2004), (Rothschild and Miethe 1994) and (Blau 1963). Through the use of (Milgrams 1974) text I will argue the detrimental effects of obedience, with reference to the Nazi occupation of Europe, and thus the need for conflict within organisations to stop such atrocities occurring again. Due to the unrealistic expectations that organisations impose on employees including required dedication and complete submission to the organisation, I argue that conflict stems from this expectation by organisations that employees will completely surrender oneself to the demands of managers. To demonstrate this point I…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Strategic Management and Employee Management Alignment

...------------------------------------------------- Strategic Management and Employee Management Alignment ALDI ------------------------------------------------- Strategic Management and Employee Management Alignment Executive Summary ALDI is a German company that is a global leader in the retail grocery industry with over 7000 stores worldwide. The company has a good reputation for their high quality products with low pricing. The purpose of this assessment is to investigate how well ALDI align their human resource strategies to the overall business strategy. The report commence with a presentation of the company’s main features, where it started and how it has developed to be an international leader. Further on, the assessment contains an explanation of what business strategy ALDI has in the organisation and what the people management processes and practices look like in the company. Lastly it identifies actual examples of people management processes and how well they are applied into the organisation. Improvements are highlighted as a way for the organisation to improve and be able to remain competitive on the international market. Key findings of this report are that the current business strategy is a cost leadership approach. The strategic management of ALDI at present is one of expansion and growth. The employee management reflects this as ALDI is participating in a period of recruitment and employee training and development. The marketing......

Words: 4155 - Pages: 17

Free Essay

Employee Management System

...Abstract This system EMS (EMPLOYEE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM) will do the management of personal details of employee’s , employee’s attendance and leave, EMS also provides information about the current leave and attendance status of the employee, which help in the approvals of the leave requests.This Software is made for any type of COMPANY to maintain the query and all the records related management of employee. It is created in Window Programming Language (i.e. PHP). The Software deals with all the work From inserting the new employee to the employee master table to showing salary report of the employees which includes authorized login, user management, maintaining the attendance of employees, Request of employee for the leave and approval of leave by the corresponding authority, calculation salary and in which department employee is working. Title of the project Employee information stystem. Objective of the project The objective of the employee information system is provide the efficient interface for user and giving the whole information about employee in which company he/she working. On the basis of his performance, attendance, and achievements of employee for organization. We can analysis the interest of employee’s towards organization and his work. It will be helpful for giving the promotion to employee’s. Software......

Words: 404 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Employee Portfolio: Management Plan

...Employee Portfolio: Management Plan MGT/311 University of Phoenix Employee Portfolio: Management Plan Riordan Manufacturing managers are developing a plan to improve their abilities to manage employees. Three employees were recently tasked with completing a series of self-assessments to identify specific characteristics and to determine how those traits affect the performance of the organization. The self- assessments analyzed job satisfaction, employee engagement, and emotions. As a result of the analysis of the assessments, additional self-assessment recommendations are included to provide greater insight for the successful management and motivation of the individual employees. J. Aguilar, Rick Smith, and Janet Mills are the employees who participated in the self-assessments. The employees took the following self-assessments: How Satisfied Am I with My Job?, Am I Engaged? And How Are You Feeling Right Now? The manager identified the strengths and weaknesses of the employees based on the assessments and developed a management plan for the organization to best capitalize on the employees’ characteristics. The results of J. Aguilar assessments indicated a job satisfaction rating below the means, exhibited high engagement, and positive emotions during the assessment. Rick Smith scored higher than the means in job performance, demonstrated high engagement, and exhibited positive emotions. Janet Mills scored below the means in job satisfaction, is only moderately......

Words: 2115 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Employee Management Plan

...Employee Portfolio Management Plan MGT/311 Employee Portfolio Management Plan In the month of September Riordan Manufacturing selected three employees and administrated a series of self-assessments to create an employee portfolio to provide a management plan. The management decided to asses each individual’s character, personality, and job satisfaction. The following self-assessment questions for the three employees: How satisfied am I with my-job, Am I engaged, How are you feeling right now, What’s my affect intensity, What’s my emotional intelligence score, Am I a deliberate decision maker. The self-assessments questions will evaluate individual characteristics of employees. Self-assessments questions will evaluate the impact of individual employee characteristics and any adverse organizational performance. The information from the assessments will determine management methods based on individual employee characteristics. The Riordan Management self-assessments of the three employees indicated strengths, weakness, opportunities and organizational behavior of the company. The self-assessment of employee in Team A is a positive influence for the Riordan Manufacturing Company. Employee in Team A, analysis is very satisfied in job satisfaction, competence in making decisions, and being able to keep busy. The employee in Team A identified problems to evaluate and made a decision or best alternative for the company. Employee in Team A is very effective in......

Words: 1110 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Employee Portfolio Management Plan

...Employee Portfolio: Management Plan The assessment of the three new employees to Riordan Manufacturing have been reviewed and summarized. The report below will give in detail each employee and give recommendations to how their characteristics will affect the performance of the organization and how they can best be assigned based on their individual responses. The report will conclude with each employee additional assessments if deemed necessary. Employee A: Employee A scored the highest in overall satisfaction and reported confident in his or her leadership, but gave evidence to being unsure of his or her place in the community and did not seem confident to instruct others. A gave a very positive attitude toward engagement and moderate views on being empathetic to others. The data displayed A to be careful decision maker with a high emotional intelligence to put thoughts first before decisions. Based on the data Employee A would continue to display loyalty and with continued exposure to the company’s goals and values contribute to enhancing our current goals and values. In the future it is recommended that Employee A receive assessments on decision making and leadership roles to potentially give him or her the opportunity to advance in a mid-level leadership role as a Team Lead or Shift Supervisor. Employee B: Employee B scored relatively high in the job satisfaction area but gave data to support the assessment that they were uncertain of what motivates them. ......

Words: 536 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Employee Portfolio Management Plan

...Employee Portfolio: Management Plan MGT/311-Organizational Development Employee Portfolio: Management Plan Employees’ values, personality, interests and skills are fundamental factors in distinguishing performing employees from incompetent. Self-assessments provide valuable feedbacks to managers to identify issues related to personality, and ideal candidates during the hiring process. In fact, “relying on an extensive amount of research, we can make some reasonably well-supported predictions of the relationship between achievement need and job performance” (Robbins & Judge, 2011, p. 3). In Riordan Manufacturing exercise, the analyzed self-assessments revealed intriguing facts about positive employees and their productivity levels. This data can potentially pay dividends towards the overall success of an organization. General attitude often sets a positive path towards high level of job satisfaction. “Job satisfaction would better predict a general behavior, such as whether the individual was engaged in her work or motivated to contribute to her organization” (Robbins & Judge, 2011, p. 112). Thus increasing the overall morale in a workplace and spreading good work ethics from one employee to another. The collected self-assessments depicted high levels of satisfaction when employees felt their managers possessed high levels of competence. Despite high level of job satisfaction, emotional intensity scored below satisfactory levels. Intangible factors (i.e. emotional......

Words: 276 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Management Employee

...Overcoming pressures on The Management Of Employee Memanage sebuah perubahan suatu tugas yang sangat rumit,dimana yang lebih baik dilakukan adalah gaya partisipatif dalam mengelola atau memenage. Gaya partisipatif dalam mengelola atau memanage adalah diaman seorang manager terlibat dalam pengambilan keputusan dan hal lainnya. Estabilish team spirit Semangat sebuah team termasuk mempercayai orang-orang di dalam suatu perusahaan bahwa mereka “terlibat bersama” dan dengan bekerja bersama sesuatu hal yang baik dapat di raih. Communicate with employee Terbuka dan seringnya berkomunikasi dengan karyawan dapat membangun rasa kepercayaan dan mengurangi rasa kuatir.Kekuatiran akan perubahan yang berkaitan dengan pertumbuhan perusahaan adalah hal yang lebih buruk dari kenyataan dari sebuah perubahan, dan komunikasi akan meringankan beberapa kecemasan tersebut. Overcoming pressure on entrepreneurs’ time Pengusaha dapat selalu menggunakan waktunya dengan baik dan benar, jika mereka lebih berusaha melakukan hal tersebut maka akan lebih memperkaya usaha mereka serta kehiupan pribadi mereka. Time management adalah sebuah proses dari perbaikan produktivitas individual melalui penggunaan waktu yang lebih efisien. 1. Increased productivity 2. Increased job satisfaction 3. Improve personal relationship Basic Principles of Time Management * Prinsip Keinginan Kesadaran bahwa sikap dan perilaku pribadi mengenai alokasi waktu harus di ubah * Prinsip......

Words: 344 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Management of Employees' Resistance to Change

...UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES RESEARCH TOPIC: MANAGEMENT OF EMPLOYEES’ RESISTANCE TO ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE BY DUMEVI ANDREW YAO AC/07-2/DS/1070 SUPERVISOR: MR. ROBERT MWIN CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION 1.0 BACKGROUND Organizations perceive change as very important for their survival and prosperity in today’s competitive environment. They make change initiative to keep up the pace with changing environment. The success and performance superiority of organizations are very much dependent on its ability to align its internal arrangement with the demand of external world. It is also recognized that as humans as we are adapting to change is very difficult more especially when it affects our comfort. Notwithstanding, change can also be accepted provided it’s well interpreted to be well understood. Management of employees’ resistance towards organizational change is one of the major problems/threats to successful change programme.My first step after discovering employee’s resistance towards organizational change management led me to the exploration of causes of resistance which have been thought by different authors as very important for overcoming it. According to Mintzberg, the cure might actually prove to be just more of the cause (Mintzberg 1998). On the other hand, organizations of today operate under increasing demands for change. The market has radically changed due to globalization, strong competition, technical development and a......

Words: 4818 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Employee Performance Management 

...Employee Performance Management is a process for establishing a shared workforceunderstanding about what is to be achieved at an organisation level. It is about aligning the organisational objectives with the employees' agreed measures, skills, competency requirements, development plans and the delivery of results. The emphasis is on improvement, learning and development in order to achieve the overall business strategy and to create a high performance workforce. How Annual Appraisals are Different But Part of Performance Management Most organisations have some type of employee appraisal system, and many are experiencing the shortcomings of manual staff evaluation systems. When discussing workforceperformance the most commonly asked question is "How does Performance Management differ from performance appraisals or staff reviews"? Performance Management is used to ensure that employees' activities and outcomes are congruent with the organisation's objectives and entails specifying those activities and outcomes that will result in the firm successfully implementing the strategy (Noe et al. 2000, p.55). An effective Performance Management process establishes the groundwork for excellence by: * Linking individual employee objectives with the organisation's mission and strategic plans. The employee has a clear concept on how they contribute to the achievement the overall business objective, * Focusing on setting clear performance objectives and expectations through the......

Words: 2513 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Employee Performance Management

...Developmental organizations embrace performance management processes that enable employees to become their greatest asset. When managers function as performance coaches, they become trainers, confronters, mentors, and counselors, providing positive feedback and reinforcement to improve skills and competencies that ultimately enhance overall employee performance. Performance management functions as an integral part of a comprehensive development strategy, although too few organizations subscribe to this philosophy (Gilley & Maycunich 2000). . Hence, the business world overflows with mediocre, stagnant, or failing organizations that stubbornly or ignorantly overlook their employees' potential. We believe that well-designed and well-executed performance management provides an excellent vehicle for promoting continuous employee and organizational growth and development (Gilley & Maycunich 2000). Developmental leaders rely on performance-oriented principles to help their organizations achieve the business results needed and to improve employee performance and productivity through continuous growth and development. These three principles performance partnership, organizational performance improvement, and effective communication provide a foundation for excellence by allowing leaders to communicate their expectations in a clear, motivating, and inspirational manner. Developmental leaders possess effective communication skills that enhance their ability to deliver......

Words: 1413 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Employee Management System

...A Project Presentation On Employee Management System Submitted By: Patel Sona B. Patel Payal J. [E.No-13084231201] [E.No-13084231170] M.Sc. (CA & IT) Semester-III Submitted To: Department of Computer Science, Ganpat University,Ganpat Vidyanagar – 384012. July/Dec-2014 1 Project Profile:Project Title Employee Management System Objectives System is used to Manage Employees, In Recruitment process choose candidate, Project Management, Client Management at one place. Platform Web Application Front End .NET Framework 4.0 with VB Back End Microsoft SQL Server 2008 Tools Visual Studio 2010, Ajax Control Toolkit 4,Crystal Report 2008 Students Name Sona Patel (13084231201) Payal Patel (13084231170) Internal Guide Hiral R. Patel Developed By Sona Patel Payal Patel Existing System:• Existing system requires manual integration of data and management of different-different processes. • Company requires different systems for Human Resource Information management, Project management and client & Product management. • Searching and tracking of information becomes complex and time consuming. Need for New System:• The new system requires to integrate systems for Human Resource Information , Client management and Project management at one place. • It makes data manipulation of projects & employees easy and fast. Its Less time consuming and provide efficient searching. FUNCTIONAL......

Words: 4574 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Employee Management

...A Project Presentation On Employee Management System Submitted By: Patel Sona B. Patel Payal J. [E.No-13084231201] [E.No-13084231170] M.Sc. (CA & IT) Semester-III Submitted To: Department of Computer Science, Ganpat University,Ganpat Vidyanagar – 384012. July/Dec-2014 1 Project Profile:Project Title Employee Management System Objectives System is used to Manage Employees, In Recruitment process choose candidate, Project Management, Client Management at one place. Platform Web Application Front End .NET Framework 4.0 with VB Back End Microsoft SQL Server 2008 Tools Visual Studio 2010, Ajax Control Toolkit 4,Crystal Report 2008 Students Name Sona Patel (13084231201) Payal Patel (13084231170) Internal Guide Hiral R. Patel Developed By Sona Patel Payal Patel Existing System:• Existing system requires manual integration of data and management of different-different processes. • Company requires different systems for Human Resource Information management, Project management and client & Product management. • Searching and tracking of information becomes complex and time consuming. Need for New System:• The new system requires to integrate systems for Human Resource Information , Client management and Project management at one place. • It makes data manipulation of projects & employees easy and fast. Its Less time consuming and provide efficient searching. FUNCTIONAL......

Words: 4574 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Employee Management

...Employee Management Walden University The main purpose of this article is to discuss ways to motivate employees in a business to help them in reaching their potential though the means of motivation. The key question the author is addressing is how can managers motivate employees. The most important information in this article is understanding that people have basic needs. The needs are: “need for achievement, need for power and need for affiliation” (Armache, 88). If managers understand that people have these needs they will be able to motivate their employees making sure their needs are fulfilled. The main inferences in this article is “Motivation is the drive that keeps people on edge to achieve their goals. When people are highly motivated the outcome could be superior and outstanding. When employees are well compensated for the efforts they put into the organization, then they are highly motivated.” (Armache, 95). If employees are happy they will perform their job duties well. If employees are happy and doing their job well it means the business will run much smoother. The key concept we need to understand in this article are employees need to be motived in some form for them to feel that they are satisfying their needs of accomplishes and achievement. If these needs go unfulfilled they will not work to the best of their ability. The main assumption underlying the author’s thinking is everyone has the same needs that they feel they have to have......

Words: 713 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Employee Portfolio: Management Plan

...MGT 311: Portfolio Management Plan Richard Fenton August 25, 2012 Pamela Harris Management Plan Portfolio Riordan Manufacturing have implemented a management plan to develop their capability of managing employees.   They have asked a few employees to complete self-assessments about their job satisfaction. These self-assessments will allow management to discover characteristics of the employees and determine how these characteristics affect Riordan Manufacturing. Self-assessments analyzed job satisfaction, emotions, how their emotions affect them, and how they make decisions. After a thorough analysis of the self-assessments, additional recommendations will be presented to assist Riordan Manufacturing gain a better perspective on the management and motivation of their employees. The participant in the Riordan Manufacturing self-assessments are Jonathan Cervantes, Lori Credico, and Holly Hunter. The following self-assessments were administered to the employees: How Satisfied Am I with My Job?, What’s My Affect Intensity?, Am I A Deliberate Decision Maker?, and How Are You Feeling Right Now? Management could identify their strengths and weaknesses manager based on the self-assessments of each employee and developed a plan on how to place employees in an area where each employee will feel more engaged in their job. Lori Credico’s self-assessments indicate a job satisfaction rating below average. Lori is affected by her moods only moderately, is a deliberate......

Words: 733 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Responses to the Use of Power in Organization May Be Resistance, Compliance or Commitment. How Can Business Leaders Deal with Employee Resistance?

...most people hate any change that does not jingle in their pockets. This resistance to change is well documented. An individual is likely to resist change for three reasons which are uncertainty, concern over personal loss and the belief that the change is not in the organization’s best interests. The leadership styles also adopted by management may also lead to resistance. According to the Harvard Business Review Magazine of 1969, one of the most baffling and recalcitrant of the problems which business executives’ face is employee resistance to change. Such resistance may take a number of forms persistent reduction in output, increase in the number of quits and requests for transfer, chronic quarrels, sullen hostility, wildcat or slowdown strikes, and, of course, the expression of a lot of pseudological reasons why the change will not work. Even the more petty forms of this resistance can be troublesome. All too often when executives encounter resistance to change, they explain it by quoting the cliché that people resist change and never look further. Yet changes must continually occur in industry. This applies with particular force to the all-important little changes that constantly take place changes in work methods, in routine office procedures, in the location of a machine or a desk, in personnel assignments and job titles. A solution which has become increasingly popular for dealing with resistance to change is to get the people involved to participate in making the......

Words: 2600 - Pages: 11