Free Essay

Debate Topic Summary Discussion

In: Business and Management

Submitted By afitaliano
Words 604
Pages 3
Debate Topic Discussion Summary

Amy F. Italiano


Thursday, January 22, 2015
Joe Monroe, MA

Debate Topic Discussion Summary

Discussion, debates, arguments are all methods of looking at a subject or an issue to reveal its real essence and the varying points of view there are. We can see the debate from several positions. The first position is clarification and problem-solving. This position has an objective to see the problem and find a viable solution. However, to see the complete picture of any given topic one must enter into a discussion with not only understanding their opinion, but a willingness to see the opposite perspective. If we can do this we perhaps, find a third less obvious avenue to travel and quite possibly a better way to come to a conclusion. Another position, that can be used, is the question of whether or not you can win or lose a debate. The arguments and persuasive facts may compel some to switch sides, but if in the end you remain in the position then was winning or losing really achieved? A third position is that debates often seem to not only continue the fight or tension between opinions but fuel them to a deeper level making it harder to find a solution.
The discussion topic, we are posing, is, "Should profiling be used as an accepted means to achieve the desired result”? Rationale for Discussion Topic Each member of Team C came up with two possible topics of discussion for this activity. We listed them and then each member gave a brief reason they chose that particular topic. We talked about each item and if it was a local, national or international issue, discussed the pros and cons of each theme and whether or not the themes were indeed controversial and could be debated. We then listed two pros and two cons for each topic to help our decision further. My decision on choosing this issue was an easy one. First, the question of whether or not to profile is very relevant in our society right now. Many decisions, that directly affect me in my everyday life and in the world around me, are the outcome of profiling or not profiling. This topic is an issue that has been around for some time now, and even though it may appear to disappear, it somehow seems to resurface continually, and it resurfaces because it’s never quite settled. Second, the quick exercise of listing pros and cons for debate on this topic was simple. As a group, we were able to come up with many on each side, which made it a very debatable topic that would be easy to defend on whichever side you choose to stand. Lastly, even in my group, we already had established opinions on both sides of this issue further deepening my decision that this topic is the one to choose. Personally, I support profiling for many reasons, one of which is that I believe that is it an effective way to get results from a target group, the desired outcome or make decisions clear.
Caution is a keyword when debating or discussing an issue. Use discretion as to what point you’re trying to make, what impression you are leaving the people you are attempting to persuade, and whether your points are fact based, emotion based or conjecture. This topic can easily lead you down a particular path if you allow it to. Use caution and try to see alternative avenues before debating so that you are not ambushed in the discussion you are trying to win.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Acct505 Week1 Discussion Summary

...Jonathan Gruenebaum Acct-505 Week 1 Summary Threaded Discussion #1 1. The Difference in Income Statements of a Service Company Vs. a Merchandising Company In a modern economy, sales revenue is the fuel that drives services, innovation and competition -- whether the income stems from a service company or a merchandising business. If you study an organization's income statement, you see things like revenues, cost of goods sold and administrative expenses -- all of which lead to net income or loss at the end of the reporting period. Income Statement When much of the economy struggles, you can look at corporation's income statement to figure out whether it's bowing to the overall negative environment or whether top leadership can maintain the business in profitable-company status. If the corporation is flourishing, you'll see that at the bottom of the statement of profit and loss -- an identical term for an income report, P&L or statement of income. Also known as the bottom line, net income equals total revenues minus total expenses. A net loss occurs if expenses exceed revenues. Service Company A service company is an organization that doesn't sell goods to make money, but rather relies on the analytical dexterity and innovation of its personnel to provide services that clients want and relish. Think of companies involved in investment banking, insurance, consulting, accounting and advisory and financial planning. In a service company's income statement, you......

Words: 696 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Debate Topics

...Debate topics: Contracts 1. Issue: breach of contract. Colorado Bicycle Tours & Rental, LLC (CBTR) ordered 75 standard touring class bicycles from BIKE, Inc. (BIKE). The terms and conditions of the purchase are set forth in the contract and accompanying purchase order. Due to a work stoppage over a labor dispute, BIKE’s production of standard touring bicycles was seriously deficient in the months following CBTR’s order placement. Because BIKE was aware of CBTR’s immediate need for bicycles (the contract stated that “time is of the essence”), BIKE shipped 23 discontinued model bicycles, 20 standard touring bicycles and 12 deluxe touring bicycles. While the discontinued bicycles were not to specification, the deluxe bicycles exceeded specifications, although they were invoiced at the same price as the standard bicycles that met specifications. After shipment, but prior to receipt of the bicycles by CBTR, the president of BIKE, Barbara Wilson, personally called Donna Dufresne, CBTR’s purchasing manager, to explain the situation and asked whether the substituted bicycles were acceptable. Dufresne reluctantly ok’d the purchase in a telephone conversation with Wilson. The contract indicated that any material changes to the agreement had to be in writing and agreed to by authorized representatives of the parties. Charlene Smythe, CBTR’s CFO, was the authorized representative of CBTR, while Wilson was BIKE’s authorized representative. When the......

Words: 8488 - Pages: 34

Free Essay

Debate Topics

...Some people think women should be allowed to join the army, the navy and the air force just like men.  To what extent do you agree or disagree? Give reasons for your answer. Write at least 250 words. model answer: Whether women should be allowed to serve in the military has triggered spirited debate. Some assert that the status quo should be changed and women should be entitled to join the armed forces. Personally, I fundamentally agree with their assertion-for three reasons. History has shown that women are fully capable of performing well in the military. Historically, there were a host of valiant women soldiers whose achievements really put their male counterparts to shame. One need only look at the classic examples of Joan of Arc and Mulan to see how exceptionally women could perform on the battlefield. In my observation, their determination, courage and dignity, to this day, are still being admired by male soldiers and civilians alike throughout the world. Moreover, from an enlightened standpoint, female patriots should be granted the right to go to the front line when their motherland is involved in a war. Admittedly, gender inequality was a highly controversial issue in the twentieth century. However, now twelve years into the new millennium, women can learn and teach, work and supervise, vote and voted in most countries just like men. In light of this sweeping progress in gender equality, there is no sense in denying them the right to defend their home......

Words: 6090 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay

W1 Discussion Topics

...This week there are four discussion topics. Complete by the due date and you will have a second chance to fix mistakes and resubmit for a second review and increased points. Name: DT1 DESCRIPTIVE STATISTICS Please read and understand before responding Topics: Central Tendency, Variability (Dispersion), Quartiles, normal data and skewed distribution of a single data group. You will want to know what measure to use when data distribution is normal (symmetrical) and when the data distribution is significantly skewed. We will work with six measures, mean, median, mode, standard deviation, interquartile range (IQR), and range. You may use a web search or the textbook. Textbook: McClave Ch. 2 pp. 54-60 (Central Tendency); pp. 64-67 (Variability); pp. 81-83 (Quartiles) Methods for Describing Sets of Data MyStatLab: Week 1 Problems supports this assignment Central Tendency (Data Center) A. Explain the strengths and weaknesses for each measure of central tendency: a) Mean, b) Median, c) Mode Mean Strengths – Shows averages of all number data Weaknesses – Averages can be thrown off with outliers Median Strengths – Shows middle number variable Weaknesses – Isn’t always exact, as there may be outliers < less sensitive to outliers is a strength. Mode Strengths– Shows most achieved results Weakness – Doesn’t paint a good picture. Not all values are used. B. Choose the best measure to use when data is normal? Choose the best measure to use when data...

Words: 1697 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Con Side Debate Summary

...Con Side Debate Summary Devin Smith 12/22/14 Steven Boylan This week for the week four learning team collaborative discussion the debate for the con side of the debate was discussed between Pamela Core and me. I started by saying how I felt about the con side and saying if I was con which means I would not want high school students to wear uniforms. My arguments would be that wearing uniforms, I could restrict students from their freedom of expression, meaning that students could loose their constitutional rights of speech and expression when entering the school doors. School uniforms promote everyone to be alike instead of promoting individuality meaning at a time when schools are encouraging an appreciation of diversity, enforcing standardized dress sends a contradictory message. Most public schools that has uniforms are place are in bad economic neighborhoods take away from the real issues at school. Meaning most public schools with uniform policies are in poor neighborhoods, emphasizing the class distinctions that uniforms were supposed to eliminate. Uniforms have an effect on self-image I believe when students have to wear the same outfits, rather than being allowed to select clothes that suit their body types, they can suffer embarrassment at school. Also students would rather not have uniforms. Pamela then began to explain her side and said that what I said is true. They are also very popular in private and Catholic Schools so the environment could be a......

Words: 534 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Con Side of Debate Summary

...Con Side of Debate Summary Should enhanced interrogation be used to protect the citizens of the United States? The answer is no. The following is a summary of the debate our team engaged in to include key points and data to support our argument. Communication Process and Effectiveness As in previous team discussions, the goal right out of the gate was to understand the objective, initiate debate and set an obtainable suspense for completion. I initiated the debate on the first day by proposing we start the discussion as soon as possible and set a deadline of Friday at 5:00pm to conclude debate. I also laid out several pros to enhanced interrogation such as the successful interrogations of Khalid Sheik Mohammad, the ticking time bomb situation and why terrorists deserve it. I also included the evil they do and would do, and made comparisons to how the terrorist’s treat their prisoners. (Messerli, 2012). The team members who responded right away concurred with the Friday deadline, and we began to comment on the five pros identified. Key Points and Supporting Arguments From the main pros discussed, our team primarily focused on three points. First, everyone agreed that just asking the terrorists nicely won’t work. In addition, enhanced interrogation is justified if it will stop another terrorist attack and/or save the lives of Americans; especially if it was a ticking time bomb scenario. Second, our team felt...

Words: 511 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Pro Side Debate Summary

...Pro Side Debate Summary Marlon D. Ector BCOM/275 2/23/2015 Michael Frank Introduction The Keystone XL Pipeline is a massive 875 mile pipe that goes across the United States from the lands of Alberta, Canada to the lands of Nebraska to connect to and exsisting pipeline and go on to the Texas Gulf Coast. It further is a costly project where numbers have totaled the values of trillions of dollars and years of work to complete this project. Pro’s When looking at this project of building a pipeline we have to look at all the things this project would do for the economy within the United States. A con to this project allows us to produce more energy and gives us the opportunity to compete in the world by moving oil at its lowest cost. Now, with all that we have been going through in these last few years of high gas prices, that bring good news to have a hope of lower prices. Then when looking at the massive size of this project through the length of time it will take to build through 1 country, and 3 states, allows you to see the vast ability to create jobs. According to the International Brotherhood of Teamsters in a 2014 article they were in agreement because it would produce 2,500 jobs for workers closer to the project and support 42,100 jobs. This would really aid the gross domestic product in a large way and help the United States in becoming major player within the market. The pipeline is one that will allow us as a Nation......

Words: 391 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Con Side of Debate Summary

...Con Side of Debate Summary Jorge Vega BCOM/125 March 26, 2015 John Kungis Common Core “Common Core government agencies will gather and store all sorts of private information on every schoolchild into a longitudinal database from birth through all levels of schooling, plus giving government the right to share and exchange this nosy [sic] information with other government and private agencies, thus negating the federal law that now prohibits that. This is what CC is; a type of surveillance and control of individual.” (Schlafly, 2013) Con Side of Debate Summary As a nation, we have trusted our government to make changes to the citizens voting rights. Where is that now how much does our vote really count? In this case Common Core was not introduce to the public schools to vote as a standard curriculum. Meaning of common core is control of the school curriculum, i.e. control by Obama administration bureaucrats. Curriculum decisions will be replaced by the Federal curriculum decisions by state and local school boards, state legislatures, parents and even Congress because Obama bypassed congress by using $4 billion of Stimulus money to promote CC. I believe that this structure is all about the money, not about having the correct tools for teaching, instructing, and guiding the student. Currently, each state sets its own standards. This has led to a nation with 50 sets of inconsistent standards, even though the expectations of colleges and employers in math and English......

Words: 957 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Bcom275 Debate Summary

...Debate Topic Summary Raj Master BCOM/275 March 23, 2015 Dr. O Pro Side Debate Summary The pro side debate summary related to the illegal immigrants being allowed to apply for a California driver’s license has several advantages. Our learning team discussed the pro side of this topic which has been considered a highly controversial subject. In 2013, the state California passed Bill AB60, which took effect in 2015 which allows illegal immigrants to apply for a driver’s license. According to Berman, when he signed the law last year, Gov. Jerry Brown (D) praised it as a way to show that these Californians did not have to hide. “No longer are undocumented people in the shadows,” he said. “They are alive and well and respected in the state of California.” Brown’s office also noted that the law explicitly prohibits these licenses being used for any sort of investigation or arrest based on immigration status. The new law makes California one of the 10 states, along with Washington D.C. and Puerto Rico, to give out licenses this way, according to the National Immigration Law Center. (Berman, 2015) The bill was written by Assemblyman Luis Alejo (D-Salinas). The assemblyman represents a district which is a center of the agricultural industry with a flourishing populating of illegal immigrant farm workers. According to, the law requires the DMV to issue a California driver's license to anyone who can satisfactorily establish California residency. If...

Words: 487 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Pro Side of Debate Discussion About Tax Exemption for Churches

...PRO SIDE OF DEBATE SUMMARY for Should Churches Remain Tax Exempt? Should Churches Remain Tax Exempt: Pro Side Debate Summary This week’s Learning Team B discussion was initiated by team members' research and posting of several arguments to support our debate topic of churches remaining tax exempt. The list of arguments reflects a comprehensive range of vantage points that include constitutionality, fiscal advantage and impact to community. Subsequent team member posts articulated individual posture or provided supplemental commentary from public opinion polls and notable expert quotes. Requiring churches to pay taxes would endanger the free expression of religion and violate the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment of the US Constitution. Supporting comments: Being a nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization directly limits the control that the government can have on how the organization is run. If churches are stripped of their 501(c)(3) status, then the government can control them and essentially force them to do and say what the government wants (Retrieved from opinion poll on the question: Should churches and other religious organizations remain tax exempt?)  A tax exemption for churches is not a subsidy to religion, and is therefore constitutional. Supporting Quote: "The grant of a tax exemption is not sponsorship, since the government does not transfer part of its revenue to churches, but simply abstains from demanding that the church support the......

Words: 662 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Topic 2 Discussion Question #1

...Topic 2 Discussion question #1 How does knowledge of the foundations and history of nursing provide a context in which to understand current practice? By having the knowledge of the foundations and history of nursing provides even the third generation nurse such as myself to understand the growth and ability to grow in the field. One must be able to identify the unsurmountable challenges faced by Florence Nightingale can empower the registered nurse throughout their career. By taking the time to study our history, each registered nurse can more effectively support the standard of evidence based practice. I was raised in a family where my grandmother, mother, aunts and cousins were all nurses. Each one in her own specialty. In my late teens, my mother went into education and taught in a school of nursing, climbing the leadership ladder to at the time of retirement she held the role as an assistant director. This being said, I always felt that I had a good exposure to the history of the profession. I was amazed as I observed the power point on areas I had no previous knowledge about and the extent of the changes we in the profession had accomplished. Identify at least three trends in nursing practice from the "Nursing Timeline of Historical Events" media piece. Nursing Uniform Transition from the Florence Nightingale area to when our grandmothers and mothers were in nursing that encompassed the hat, white stockings and white dress with pockets. To the......

Words: 585 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Topic 7 Chapter Discussion Question with certain countries which would have a negative impact on supply chain efficiency. 11.  Why is top management commitment necessary for successful supply chain management? Top management has the ability to allocate the necessary resources for supply chain endeavors and top management has the power to structure, or restructure, corporate incentive policies to focus on achieving organizational or interorganizational (as opposed to functional) objectives. 12.  Some companies are hesitant to use frequent shopper cards because the data provided could violate the customer’s privacy. Do you agree or disagree? Why? Although either answer is acceptable, the question of data usage versus customer privacy has generated impassioned discussions by students. On the one hand, the frequent shopper cards can provide a plethora of data about the shopping habits of particular consumers, potentially allowing stores to achieve customized marketing for individual customers. At the same time, frequent shopper cards could violate customer privacy in the sense that certain customers might be uncomfortable that stores have access to such detailed data about them, particularly if the data includes frequent purchases of potentially “embarrassing” products (e.g., laxatives). 13.  Discuss the best of breed and single integrator approaches. In a single integrator approach, all relevant software applications (e.g., inventory management, transportation management, warehouse management,......

Words: 1568 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Critical Thinking Discussion & Summary

...Critical Thinking Discussion & Summary Tina Cullors PHL/320 February 29, 2016 Bridget Peaco University of Phoenix Critical thinking is a way of making decisions both personally and professionally. Without critical thinking our decision making would all be knee jerk reactions and would cause chaos in your life. In discussion we will have identified what is critical thinking by identifying the premise and how we arrived to the conclusion. I define critical thinking as a process of how to analyze and evaluate the question, topic of conversation or situation, before forming an opinion or just reacting. Being able to make a clear judgment. A critical thinker is someone that does not make a conclusion on an instant with information presented. A critical thinker analyzes the information, and obtains necessary information to support the premise. Critical thinking is importation because you obtain an amount of information to make an argument that your find to be true that brings you to your conclusion with a convincing argument to justify your claim. I use critical thinking both in my personal and professional life. For example, if I am thinking of buying a new car I have to look at not how my decision will just impact my finances now but how my decision affects me long term; like can I afford to take money from my savings for the down payment and what will payment be for 36 or 48 months. As for my work when I am modernizing a school......

Words: 384 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Topic 1: Discussion Question 2

...Topic 1: Discussion Question 2 I reminisce to the excitement of the first day of school as I begin the next chapter of my educational journey. The sweet feeling of unknown, the butterflies in the stomach bring about childhood memories. I am looking forward to expanding my knowledge, the joy of overcoming the challenges and most importantly, earning my BSN. I have my goals set clearly before me and my motivation is strong. I know I can overcome my fear of failure as I have done in the past. My fears almost caused me to give up during my LPN to RN bridge program. I felt overwhelmed and lost confidence in myself. Thankfully I had a strong support system. I was able to refocus on my goals, prioritize and utilize my resources to overcome my fears of failure and succeed. With hard work and determination I regained my confidence and drive to become a professional and a scholar. From that point there was no turning back. I have too much at stake to allow self-doubt to interfere with my goals. Although I encountered a setback during my bridge program I was able to complete it and earn my associate degree. I am glad I had that experience. It made me more confident in myself and more aware of my strengths and weaknesses as a student. I think it is naïve for a person to believe they will never fail. That mid set handicaps a student’s mind. I feel that knowing and accepting one’s fears is the best way to not fall into their depths. References: Lake, A., & von Baeyer, C.......

Words: 313 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Operations Topic Summary

...for recording financial transactions, so that a summary of what has happened to the business money can be traced. Every financial transaction should be recorded and entered into accounts that can be summarized into financial reports. Financial reports and statements provide information about the trading period. These statements are set out in a standard format that is easy to read and understand. The main types of financial reports and statements are: * Cash flow statements Provide information about the liquidity of the business * Income statements Outline income received and expenses incurred by the business in the course of period of trading * Balance sheets Detail the financial stability of the business in terms if what is owns and what is owes A business is an economic entity that trades within society and has a responsibility to internal and external stakeholders. Accounting provides information that is valuable to managers. It provides information about employees, owners and shareholders, suppliers, competitors, consumers, government and general public. Accounting is useful because it provides statements about a businesses financial status, cash status, cash flows, profitability, trends in borrowings nd earnings. The main purpose of accounting is planning that is purposeful, encourage financial decision making and confidence in the business management. 6. What are financial statements: Reports that summaries transactions over a period of time.......

Words: 707 - Pages: 3