Premium Essay

Commodity vs Capital Fetishism

In: Social Issues

Submitted By developed
Words 16098
Pages 65
Commodity Fetishism vs. Capital Fetishism
Marxist Interpretations vis-à-vis Marx’s analyses in Capital

Dimitri Dimoulis and John Milios
Abstract In Marx’s analysis of the Capitalist Mode of Production and more precisely in his theory of value, the key to decipher the capitalist political and ideological practices and structures is to be found. In this context, many Marxists believed that the analysis of “commodity fetishism” in Section 1 of Volume 1 of Capital renders the basis for understanding ideological domination and political coercion under the capitalist rule. The authors argue, that “commodity fetishism” is only a preliminary notion, which allows Marx to arrive, in subsequent Sections of Capital, at the concept of the “fetishism of capital”.

1. Introduction
From the days of his youth Marx was familiar with the statements of ethnographers on the subject of fetishism and used the term in his own writings.1 Equally important was in this context the influence of Hegel.2 In this paper we are not going to deal with the different meanings that the notion of fetishism acquires at different points of Marx’s work, an issue which is related to the various concepts of fetishism in political economy, political philosophy and the social sciences.3 We will focus on the analysis of commodity fetishism, in an effort to contribute to the comprehension of the different dimensions of this concept, especially in Marx’s Capital. For this purpose, we will pursue the following course: At the beginning we are going to present various Marxist approaches to the subject. Subsequently, we are going to read these approaches in the light of Marx’s analysis. In this way we will attempt to investigate if and to what extent the notion of fetishism has itself attained a fetishist function within Marxism, creating inversions, transpositions and misinterpretations, and what is actually…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Commodity Trading

... TRADING IN COMMODITIES SUBMITTED TO: SUBMITTED BY: MS.PALLAVI DAWRA DEEPAK JASLEEN NEHA TASHNEET INTRODUCTION Commodity trading in India is regulated by the Forward Markets Commission (FMC) headquartered at Mumbai, it is a regulatory authority which is overseen by the Ministry of Consumer Affairs and Public Distribution, Govt. of India. It is a statutory body set up in 1953 under the Forward Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1952. COMMODITY TRADINGCommodity markets are quite like equity markets. The commodity market also has two constituents i.e. spot market and derivative market. In case of a spot market, the commodities are bought and sold for immediate delivery. In case of a commodities derivative market, various financial instruments having commodities as underlying are traded on the exchanges. It has been seen that traditionally in India people have hedged their risks with Gold and Silver. | COMMODITY FUTURESCommodity future is a derivative instrument for the future delivery of a commodity on a fixed date at a particular price. The underlying in this case is a particular commodity. If an investor purchases......

Words: 2241 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay


...differentiate commodity futures from stocks, bonds and other conventional assets. The article also explains in details the mechanics of investment in commodity futures and providing data on its historical returns in comparisons with other assets classes. The articles also elaborated the effects of inflation to commodity futures. Citation Gary Gorton & K. Geert Rouwenhorst (June 2000). Facts and Fantasies About Commodity Futures retrieved from: Introduction This review critically reviews the article ‘Facts and Fantasies About Commodity Futures which was retrieved from  The review will firstly summarize the article. Secondly, it will briefly analyze the effectiveness of the article’s structure, investigating how the information is set out and whether the reader can access it efficiently.  Thirdly, the review will critique the article, evaluating its accuracy, currency, relevance, objectivity and stability. The review will also judge the article’s accessibility and credibility. Overall the article was well written, clear and relevant. Brief Summary This articles was written to study simple properties of commodity futures as an asset class. Apart from explaining the mechanics of investment in commodity futures, the article explained the degree of relationship between spot and futures in term of return and risk. The article also elaborated in detail the different behavior between commodity......

Words: 773 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Commodities and Free Labor: Marx and Terranova

...Capitalism, as an economy driven by hyper-consumption, is based on commodities. The role of the commodity in the labor force has been thoroughly discussed throughout various eras, and in recent years, the general account of the commodity itself has had to adapt to the constantly changing and developing digital media industry and digital economy. Karl Marx wrote in The Fetishism of the Commodity that commodities are seen as objects with intrinsic value and cloud the labor-exploiting mechanisms that produced them. Tiziana Terranova, a more current thinker, draws on early Marxist thought in Free Labor: Producing Culture for the Digital Economy, but also accounts for the changes the digital media industry produced on the labor force, the very concept of a commodity, and capitalism as a whole. Marx is the first to state that capitalism is based on the accumulation and hyper-consumption of commodities. As such, commodities are meaningful both because of their monetary/exchange value and because they reflect the social relations of production that went into making them. In The Fetishism of the Commodity, Marx says that the inherent problem with the capitalist structure is that society tends to focus only on the monetary and exchange value of the commodity. Marx uses the word “fetish” to describe commodities and show how they cause society to fixate on their monetary and exchange values, while ignoring the exploitative nature of the market that produced them. To illustrate his......

Words: 1221 - Pages: 5

Free Essay


...“The Fetishism of the Commodity and its Secret” Response” While I was reading this section in Marx’s “Capital Volume One” I really didn’t understand what far out, groundbreaking point Marx was trying to make. He kept going on and on for way too long on different points he could make very clearly in a sentence or two. Overall, the point that Marx was trying to get at was how the value of a commodity and the magnitude of labor to create a final product affected its worth. Obviously the more valuable a commodity, the more valuable what you make out of it will be. I don’t quite understand how Marx can say this was discovered by a “scientific study” since it is rather simple, but either way he’s correct about how an item made of a more valuable commodity makes it a more valuable product. Anybody looking to turn a resource into a new product in search of making a profit understands this very well. Nobody in their right mind is going to take an expensive resource like gold, mold it into some type of jewelry, and charge less for it than what the raw gold is worth. Scarcity is what drives the price of gold to be so high at $1,725/oz. right now. Since gold is a hard resource to find it makes it more valuable. On the other hand, a resource like wood isn’t going to be an expensive resource since it’s so readily available and common. Wood comes from trees which are found almost everywhere in the world. Being that it’s so easy to obtain, if I make some sort of product out of wood......

Words: 649 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

An in-Depth Look at Darden Restaurants, Inc. vs. Barington Capital Group Lp

...SPLITTING THE CHECK: AN IN-DEPTH LOOK AT DARDEN RESTAURANTS, INC. vs. BARINGTON CAPITAL GROUP LP Table of Contents Executive Summary 4 Position 5 Sense 6 Uncover 7 Solve 8 Build 9 Achieve 10 Bibliography 23 Executive Summary This is the first paragraph of your executive summary. It should be indented, it should be double-spaced, and it should be in 12 pt Times New Roman font (as should the rest of the body of your term paper). An executive summary should be no longer than two pages (and preferably shorter), and should be written after your paper has been completed. It is a complete summary of your recommendations, and the reader should get a clear picture from this section alone. Assume that the reader reads nothing else. Darden Restaurants, Inc., a multi-billion dollar full-service restaurant company, is facing – and will be facing many difficult challenges. In addition to billions in lost revenue from the economic downturn and a severe shortage in their most served menu item, they have recently been challenged by a new minority shareholder who is pressuring them to reorganize their corporate structure. This activist investor, Barington Capital Group, LP, is known for being particularly aggressive and frequently getting what they want. Darden’s revenues are down significantly over the last couple of years in their two flagship – and typically most profitable restaurants, Red......

Words: 5656 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Branding of Commodities

... BRANDING OF COMMODITIES By: Sumit Gupta MBA(IB)-2002-04 IIFT, New Delhi DATE: 2nd September, 2003 This document is created using PDFmail (Copyright RTE Software) ABSTRACT By definition, commodities are products and services that customers perceive to be exactly the same. A market becomes a commodity market if the suppliers choose not to differentiate themselves, either through their products/services, or through their brands. Equally, any market can become a branded market if the suppliers choose to differentiate themselves. But companies that sell products such as bulk chemicals, paper, and steel or milk, salt, cement, etc. tend to emphasize operations and sales over marketing, striving to unload as much inventory as possible at the prevailing market price. Viewing themselves as commodity producers, they particularly overlook the nonfunctional features of their products—delivery speeds, aftersales service, distribution, Pricing, Customer servicing, Segmentation, Positioning and Communication. What these producers lose out on is the opportunity to increase their gross margins, create consumer demand for their specific items(s), and build valuable Brand Equity by employing the branding practices made successful by consumer packaged goods enterprises. The biggest challenge facing manufacturers today is how to differentiate their commodity so that their business rises above the commodity market place to enjoy the......

Words: 3607 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Commodities and Commodity Derivatives

...FAO COMMODITY AND TRADE POLICY RESEARCH WORKING PAPER No.22 Threshold cointegration in the sugarethanol-oil price system in Brazil: evidence from nonlinear vector error correction models George Rapsomanikis and David Hallam1 Commodities and Trade Division Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations September 2006 1 The authors are Economist and Chief in the Trade Policy Service, Commodities and Trade Division. FAO Commodity and Trade Policy Research Working Papers are published by the Commodities and Trade Division of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). They are working documents and do not reflect the opinion of FAO or its member governments. Also available at Additional copies of this working paper can be obtained from The designations employed and the presentation of material in this information product do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations concerning the legal or development status of any country, territory, city or area or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. All rights reserved. Reproduction and dissemination of material in this information product for educational or other non-commercial purposes are authorized without any prior written permission from the copyright holders provided the source is fully acknowledged.......

Words: 7956 - Pages: 32

Premium Essay

Transvestic Fetishism

...Jennifer Gay Okefenokee Technical College Psychology 1101 July 7, 2014 Abstract Transvestic fetishism is defined as sexual arousal which is brought upon by fantasizing and wearing clothing designed specifically for the opposite sex. This disorder more commonly affects men who prefer woman’s clothing, undergarments or other items. This is partly due to the fact that many men’s styles today are also appropriate for women. The difference is when a man chooses hosiery, makeup or high heeled shoes it becomes out of place in society. The disorder affects mainly heterosexual or bisexual men who usually prefer sexual relations with women. The disorder is not usually diagnosed unless the fetish begins to interfere with the person’s normal, everyday life. Transvestic fetishism is defined by the mental health professional’s handbook, the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders fourth edition text revision (DSM-IV-TR), as a paraphilia. A paraphilia is a mental disorder characterized by obsession with unusual sexual practices or with sexual activity involving non-consenting or inappropriate partners (such as children or animals). The most prevalent features of transvestic fetishism is recurrent intense sexual urges and sexually arousing fantasies involving dressing in clothing associated with members of the opposite sex. A commonly used term for transvestic fetishism is cross-dressing and people who frequently engage in cross-dressing are sometimes called......

Words: 1223 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

An Overview of Fetishism

...An Overview of Fetishism Individuals across cultures are diagnosed with all different types of sexual disorders. A sexual disorder is classified as a disorder that involves sexual functioning, desires, or performance (Mosby 2009). These disorders have a huge affect on people because they can affect their own personal social lives. There are many sexual disorders and dysfunctions that individuals suffer from. Along with these disorders, there are many different factors and many treatments that have been used to help these individuals. One specific sexual disorder is Fetishism, which was first explained by Sigmund Freud. Much more research needs to be done to explain this disorder because it is not completely clear at this time. Fetishism is a sexual disorder, which is also a form of paraphilia where the patient has reoccurring sexual fantasies that usually involve a nonliving object. The object has a connection with sex and sexual gratification. An individual is diagnosed with this disorder when they act on these urges, are distressed by them, or must have the object to receive gratification (“Fetishism,” 2010). The demographics for Fetishism in the world or United States is not known because these patients are not counted or tracked unless in rare instances where the patient has a desire to be counted. This disorder is usually more popular with males than females. There is also no information on whether genetics has any effect on the disorder (Fallon,......

Words: 847 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Capital Punishment vs Human Rights

...responsibility and the legal authority to punish the criminal or groups of criminals based on the given law. The punishment of the criminals may vary from simple fines and imprisonment to sever torture and the deprivation of life. Capital punishment or the death penalty has existed as part of the human justice system since ancient times. In these earlier periods people were sentenced to death as a punishment for crimes considered as first degree offenses by the state. These crimes were most of the time political as well as religious and the method of execution, in addition to different brutal ways, was mainly beheading. With additional types of crimes resulting in capital punishment and more sophisticated methods of execution, the death penalty has continued to be practiced in the 21st century. However, capital punishment, especially after the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948, has became an issue of greater debate among states, human right organizations and other nongovernmental organizations. Since 1948, the number of countries employing death penalty is decreasing and currently nearly half of the states in our world have abandoned the death penalty for all kinds of crimes. This paper will focus on presenting the diverging views regarding capital punishment mainly from a human right perspective. The study then tries to present facts, figures, and tries to look in brief the move towards its universal abolition. As far as the methods and methodology......

Words: 4873 - Pages: 20

Free Essay

Commodity Research

...India, a country with a population of over one billion, has an economy based on agriculture, precious metals and base metals. Thus, trading in commodities provides lucrative market opportunities for a wider section of participants of diverse interests like investors, arbitragers, hedgers, traders, manufacturers, planters, exporters and importers. But surprisingly it has an under developed commodity market. The commodity market in India is in very nascent stage of growth. It taps only .4% of the markets. Hence shows huge scope of growth in future. This projects aims to throw light upon into this potential market. To brief about the evolution of commodity markets there is a look into the past giving the overview of the commodity market in India. Various commodities exchanges MCX AND NCDEX work for developing commodity market in India. Major reforms have been initiated in commodity futures markets in India in the last few years along with the analysis about the present scenario of commodity market in India. These efficient risk management tools insulate buyers and sellers from unexpected changes in future price movements. Understanding role the participants of future markets - hedgers, speculators and arbitragers. The second phase of the project deals with the Energy sector of the commodity exchange viz. Crude oil and its determinants in particular for in depth analysis. It includes fundamental analysis for crude oil. How the behavior of crude oil price has significant......

Words: 310 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Capital Markets of Philippines vs. Hong Kong

...I. Overview of the Hong Kong Capital Market Located in the heart of Asia, Hong Kong positioned itself to be a major international financial center of the continent. Its capital market is comprised of integrated network of institutions and markets which provide a wide range of products and services to local and international customers and investors. Hong Kong’s financial markets are characterized by a high degree of liquidity and operate under effective and transparent regulations, which meet international standards. The Government of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (HKSAR) abides by the principle of keeping intervention into the way in which the market operates to a minimum and has endeavoured to provide a favorable environment in which business operates. Its policy of low and simple taxation allows maximum room for business initiatives and innovation. There is a strong emphasis on the rule of law and fair market. There are no barriers of access to the market by foreign businesses and no restrictions on capital flows into and out of Hong Kong. Hong Kong’s privileged location in the Northeast Asia, on the other hand, makes it a gateway to China. Moreover, Hong Kong is situated at appropriate time zones that allow 24-hour continuous trading of foreign exchange and gold when the two markets in New York and London are closed. II. Financial Players and Intermediaries in Hong Kong Preview:A closer look at the financial markets As of July 2010, there......

Words: 13954 - Pages: 56

Premium Essay

Commodity Swaps

...POLICY RESEARCH WORKING PAPER 1667 Dealing with Commodity Price Uncertainty Plantos Varangis Dont Larson Market liberalization has increased the appeal of commodity derivative instruments (such as futures, options, swaps, and commodity-linked notes)as a means of managing price uncertainty. many In emerging countries both government and the private sector are increasinglyusing these instruments. The World Bank International Economics Department Commodity Policy and Analysis Unit October 1996 POLICYRESEARCH WORKINGPAPER1667 Summary findings Liberalization in commodity markets has brought profound changes in the way price risks are allocated and managed in commodity subsectors. Price risks are increasingly allocated to private traders and farmers rather than absorbed by the government. The success of market reform depends on the ability of the emerging private sector to make full use of the available range of modern commodity marketing, price risk management (such as futures, options, swaps, commodity bonds, and so on), and financing instruments. Because farmers do not generally have direct access to these instruments, interinediaries must be developed. Larger private traders and banks are in the best position to become these intermediaries. Preconditions needed for accessing modern commodity marketing, price risk management, and financing instruments are: * Creating an appropriate legal, regulatory, and institutional framework. * Reducing......

Words: 4953 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay


...Recent geopolitical and economic developments which caused major movements in the commodities market have been reflected in this report. Continuous rise of copper demand in industrial use and narrowing supply of copper globally has led to rise in copper prices. The US Dollar affects the price of copper and has been a significant driver of copper prices for a long time. Due to recent economic developments, the copper prices and USD relationship has become more complicated. The Indian copper demand is primarily for Electrical and Industrial purpose with the major demand coming from three industries, i.e. Consumer Products, Electricity (especially Transmission & Distribution), and the Telecommunication Industries. India, with its present economic growth prospects, holds an important position in the copper market. Worldwide market demand for copper is also growing, while supplies of copper are quickly disappearing. New high-tech uses for copper will further strain already-tight supplies in the future. For copper to shine, it needs much more investment demand. This will happen because as the dollar loses more value, and at a more rapid pace, people all over the world will turn to gold first, and then to copper. TABLE OF CONTENTS |Sr. |Chapter |Page No. | |1 |Introduction to Commodities ......

Words: 8266 - Pages: 34

Premium Essay

Capital Investments vs. Operational Expenses

...Capital Investments vs. Operational Expenses MBE 503: Accounting and Ethics Instructor James Wright Kimberly Stringer Regular expenses can be expensed as they are incurred or they can be capitalized. Day to Day functions of a business require operating expenses in order to run. Operational Expense (OPEX) include sales and general administrative expenses which do not include cost of goods sold or COGS, taxes, depreciation or interest. Operating expenses show on the profit and loss whereas capital expenditures show as major investments and show on the balance sheet and are depreciated over time ( Marketing expenses are usually operating expense unless it shown that it has long term benefits. Some believe that if a company is expected rapid growth the recording items as an operating expense is better. However, Bernard Golden from believes otherwise. “Once you have purchased a capital good, you’re stuck with it, as anyone who has purchased a car understands; even if you’re no longer excited about owning it, the finance company still expects a monthly payment. By contrast if you rent a car, you are committed to it only as long as you want to use it and once you have paid for that use, you have no further financial obligation”. Companies usually want to direct their investment into generating revenue and this is why they would rather lease than purchase (Logicalis, 2013). Some expenditures for startup costs can be capitalized in the......

Words: 950 - Pages: 4