Premium Essay

Case 1.1: Made in the U.S.A.—Dumped in Brazil, Africa, Iraq…

In: Business and Management

Submitted By JMcClure
Words 350
Pages 2
CASE 1.1: Made in the U.S.A.—Dumped in Brazil, Africa, Iraq…
Dumping refers to the practice of exporting to other countries products that have been banned or declared hazardous in the United States (Shaw, 2010, pg. 43). Based on the definition alone it seems that it would not only be immoral but illegal to promote dumping; however even if dumping was considered legal it does not make it moral. According to our textbook, “Legality should not be confused with morality. Breaking the law isn’t always or necessarily immoral and the legality of an action doesn’t guarantee its morality” (Shaw, 2010, pg. 12).
It is understandable that any company would want to make a profit, or in times of loss whenever possible recover from a bad investment; however the decisions that are made in these times should not be focused solely on monetary recovery. The company needs to consider how its actions will affect others as well as moral consequences. In the case study it refers to companies who bypass the law by selling the products separately and later combine them to create the product that is illegal, although this could be considered legal it is simply a bad moral choice. It is morally wrong to make a choice to protect one group of people while ignoring the safety of another, which is exactly what occurs in the process of dumping.
Moral considerations that would support dumping products overseas, even though this violates U.S. law, could be made based on the needs of those in the foreign countries. It could be said that other countries should be free to decide for themselves whether or not the benefits of the products being dumped are worth the risk. If the law states that another country cannot purchase products that the U.S. has deemed bad, despite the risks, we are taking away the other countries right to choose and instead making choices for them. While it is morally…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Natura: Global Beauty Made in Brazil

...Natura: Global Beauty Made in Brazil I. Situation Analysis The beauty market has experienced exponential growth rates and is an important sector in many countries—particularly Brazil – a country known for its cultural importance of self-image. Amidst a highly competitive beauty industry with a number of major global players, one local gem stands out from the crowd – Natura. Founded in 1969, the company is the industry leader in cosmetics, fragrances and personal care market in Brazil. Natura developed it products using environmentally sustainable practices and employed a direct sales business model, which has overtaken Avon, the giant U.S. company. Natura provides a wide range of products with solutions for consumers’ various needs including face care, body care, hair care, make-up, fragrances, oral hygiene and product lines for children. The company was tremendously successful in Brazil despite the tough economy. Natura began its international expansion in 1982 around the neighborhood countries, starting with Chile followed by Argentina, Peru and recently Mexico in 2003. However it was in 2005 that Natura took a major step in its internationalization by opening a shop in Paris, the world capital of beauty and cosmetics. The analysis below examines and evaluates a strategic decision for future international expansion for Natura – whether it is to stay within Latin America and Europe, enter the attractive US market or expand to fast-growing Russia? And as part of the growth......

Words: 1157 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Case 1.1

...s e c TIo n client acceptance C a s es inC lu de d in t his se Ction 1 3 1.1 Ocean Manufacturing, Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The New Client Acceptance Decision InsTrucTor resource Manual — Do noT copy or reDIsTrIbuTe InsTrucTor resource Manual — Do noT copy or reDIsTrIbuTe ocean Manufacturing, Inc. The new client acceptance Decision ins tr uC t ional o b je C t ive s [1] To c a s e 1.1 Mark S. Beasley · Frank A. Buckless · Steven M. Glover · Douglas F. Prawitt help students understand the process of considering a new prospective audit client and the factors that auditors commonly consider in making the acceptance decision. [2] To give students experience in computing and interpreting preliminary analytical procedures commonly used in obtaining an understanding of a prospective client during the client acceptance decision process. [3] To raise issues relating to auditor independence in the context of client acceptance, both in terms of financial interests and the provision of non-audit services. To illustrate the subjective and sometimes difficult nature of the judgments involved in the client acceptance decision, and to give students the opportunity to justify a recommendation on client acceptance in the presence of both significant positive and negative factors. [5] To help students understand how information gathered in the client acceptance process can help the auditor in planning the audit if the......

Words: 4495 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Business Ethics Case 1.1

...Case 1.1 1a. Whether or not dumping should be permitted is a moral question. 1b. "Are dangerous products of any use in the third world?" is a nonmoral question. 1c. "Is it proper for the U.S. government to sponsor the export of dangerous products overseas?" is a moral question. 1d. Whether or not the notification system works as its supporters claim it works is a nonmoral question. 1e. "Is it legal to dump this product overseas?" is a nonmoral question. 2. Dumping is a method of getting rid of unwanted products or substances that are harmful to people, animals, or the environment by exporting them to other countries in order to make a profit or mitigate a loss. An example used in the text is the flame resistant pajamas that were recalled because they contained Tris. These pajamas were dumped in overseas markets to help negate the company’s loss. 3. Dumpers dump because they want to either make a profit or avoid a loss in profit. I am sure some of the companies employees may have second thoughts on dumping, but not “making your number” can be quite a motivator to sidestep your moral beliefs. If I were one of the manufacturers of the Tris pajamas, I would have a hard time sending a product that I know to be toxic to a market with less restrictive regulations, but I think ultimately, I would do it if all information was disclosed not only to the government, but to the end purchaser as well. 4. Just because no laws may be broken does not mean it is......

Words: 778 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Case 1.1 Enron

...Case 1.1 Enron Corporation Saint Leo University 1. a. Andersen auditors – the auditors from Andersen failed to properly perform their professional auditing duties. b. Enron Board of Directors and top executives – the Enron executives focused on creating the foremost corporation, and with that goal performed many actions that would lead to the demise of Enron. Specifically, Kenneth Lay, Jeffrey Skilling, and Andrew Fastow are the masterminds behind the scheme. c. Accounting regulators – at the time of Enron, there was not as much regulation as there is post-Enron, so while there was no one specifically at fault for catching Enron in their actions, there should have been more regulation put in place as there is today to prevent this fraud. 2. a. Executive professionals search/human resource services – a company’s auditing firm cannot also provide employee search services for them. The potential executives have a large amount of power in the company, therefore relating the two can serve as a powerhouse for internal fraud. b. Software design services – if the company’s auditor is the designer of the software being audited, there would be a large amount of bias on the auditor’s part to put the software in a positive light. This would make it difficult for the company to see where real improvements need to be made. c. Investment adviser – essentially the auditor’s job description is to evaluate the firm’s financial escapades. If an auditor suggests a certain......

Words: 811 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Case 1.1 Enron

...Case 1.1- Enron Corporation 1) The Enron debacle created what one public official reported was a “crisis of confidence” on the part of the public in the accounting profession. List the parties who you believe were most responsible for that crisis. Briefly justify each of your choices. * Both the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Financial Accounting Standards Board had a hand in lack of the public’s confidence in the accounting profession. Due to the lack of regulation for SPEs at the time of Enron scandal, companies found it easy to exploit the “3 percent” loophole, which allowed them to avoid having to consolidate the SPEs balance sheets with their everyday operations. This, in turn, allowed companies to move liabilities off balance sheet without having to make too many disclosures. The lack of directive by the SEC and FASB made it acceptable for companies to report inflated gains on various misleading transactions. * Next, the audit firms that deviated from their fiduciary duty to their clients and the public contributed greatly to the crisis in the accounting profession. There is an inherent conflict of interest when a firm begins providing audit services and a wide range of consulting services; the firm loses its objectivity when it helps a client to pursue aggressive, irresponsible accounting tactics. In the Enron case, Andersen was complicit in the aggressive accounting schemes and nefarious financial reporting for its SPE......

Words: 1134 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Marketing Case : Natura in Brazil

...| case study | | | 17/02/2014 | Natura : Global Beauty Made in Brazil | | David Molina 11185093 | case study Natura : Global Beauty Made in Brazil | | | What are the key success factors in the cosmetics industry?We’re going to go with a step by step analysis, similar to a PEST analysis, in order to find the key factors in the cosmetic industry, especially in Brazil and according to the article.First, the political reforms in Brazil in the 1990s has led to a better openness of trade and investment from the global market. From 1995 to 2000, it has created a more decentralized and market-driven environment through the deregulation of state monopolies and prices, according to the WTO report of trade policies in Brazil in November 2000. It also explains the influence of better resource allocation and greater flexibility of the Brazilian market on the recovering from the financial crisis that lead to the floating of the real in 1999, and thus show an increasing resistance of the market.On the other side, the economic structure of Brazil was supporting the development of the cosmetic market. In 2005, it has 180 million of people which 83% were located in urban areas, which are targeted consumers for cosmetic products. Also there was a strong demand for cosmetic products in Brazil, the country being among the top ranked countries in term of sales. Before the 1990s, there was also a lack of international competition in Brazil, a few multinational were......

Words: 2241 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Case

...anything wrong with dumping? If so when is it wrong and why? Do any moral considerations support dumping products overseas when this violates U.S. law? These are the questions being asked when it comes to the controversial issues of dumping. The case of “Made in the USA-Dumped in Brazil, Africa, Iraq…” brings up dumping issues and demonstrates that both the consumers and the manufactures have valid arguments. What is dumping? The term dumping refers to the practice of exporting to other countries products that have been bonded or declared hazardous in the United States (Shaw. 32.) According to the last portion of the questions asked, if dumping overseas violates U.S. law, the answer is quite simple….yes, because it is illegal and wrong. As with every debate or issue there are two sides. With the debate of dumping the two sides are consumers and manufacturers. One can argue that the manufacturers lack respect for life when it comes to a consumer of these dangerous products being dumped on overseas markets. The company should have the best interest to take in consideration the health and safety of people and animals. The manufactures are knowingly making dangerous products available to communities to third world countries. The case study makes the point that some of these third world governments demand access to these products, otherwise it is stated that the U.S. are violating their national sovereignty. Even so this is wrong and unethical if it is known that the......

Words: 469 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Case 1.1

...Case 1.1 Intel A. The type of business in which Intel operates is world’s largest semiconductor chip maker. They develop advanced technology, primarily integrated circuits, for industries such as computing and communications. Their Integrated circuits are semiconductor chips etched with interconnected electronic switches. They also develop computing platforms, which we define as integrated hardware and software computing technologies that are designed to provide an optimized solution. They do this all based on their revenue. B. From the letters from the chairman and CEO the analyst can learn that Intel reported their best financial results in 2010. The broadband for intel products across all regions continued to grow. Operating income rose to 15.6% billion, which was a net income of 11.5 billion and earning shares rose to $2.01. Their use of recycling of factory reuse drove the cost down. Intel will need to be aggressive with keeping up with the modern technology such as smartphones, tablets etc. to continue to grow. The total dividend payout for 2010 was $3.5 billion. The new intel processor has increased the data center group revenue 35% over 2009. This information can help the analyst to see what type of revenue and how the revenue is coming in to help create a financial projects for next year. C. The audit opinion that Intel recieved was stated to be fairly accurate to Intel financial position for the past 3 years. They stated that the information......

Words: 404 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Case Study 1.1

...Case 1.1 Diseases of the Skin and Eyes You are out to coffee with your friend Diane, when she confides that she and her husband Ted are thinking of starting a family. She goes on to say that she has just come back from a checkup with her OB/GYN. “The doctor said I am healthy and everything,” she says, “but she wants to see my immunization records, to make sure I have been vaccinated for rubella before I get pregnant.” You nod. Diane wants to know why this vaccination would be important for her. 1. What is rubella? Rubella (German measles) is an infection caused by the rubella virus. Although it most commonly occurs in young children, it can affect anyone. The illness is usually mild. However, rubella in a pregnant woman can cause serious damage to the unborn child. 2. Why would Diane’s doctor be concerned about Diane’s immunity to rubella? If a pregnant women has rubella, the virus is likely to cause serious damage to the unborn child or cause a miscarriage. Rubella can lead to damage to the heart, brain, hearing and sight. The baby is likely to be born with a very serious condition called the congenital rubella syndrome. Diane thanks you for your clear explanation. “I probably won’t be able to find my immunization records: you know I wasn’t raised in the U.S.” But Diane is not worried. “I think I had rubella as a child. I remember being very sick with a rash, high fever, and white spots in my throat. I even had to be in the hospital for a......

Words: 424 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Case 1.1 Waste Management

...Danielle A. Smalls ACC 747 Advanced Topics in Auditing July 21, 2015 Case 1.1 Waste Management Case 1.1 Waste Management: The Expense Recognition Principle 1. The expense recognition principle also known as the “matching” principle is when expenses should be recognized in the same period as the revenues to which they relate. This principle is important to users of financial statements because if this principle is not followed stakeholders of a company can be deluded to thinking a company is earning profits when it really is not. Which would lead investors into investing in a company they normally would not. 2. Waste management violated the expense recognition principle by making numerous unsupported changes to the estimated useful lives and/or salvage values of one or more categories of vehicles, containers and equipment. Such changes reduced the amount of depreciation expense recorded in a particular period. An entry that may have been use by Waste Management for fraud would be a debit to the accumulated depreciation and a credit to the depreciation expense. 3. Paragraph 2 of PCAOB Auditing Standard No. 5 states “effective internal control over financial reporting provides reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting and the preparation of financial statements for external purposes. 3/ If one or more material weaknesses exist, the company's internal control over financial reporting cannot be considered......

Words: 440 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Case Brazil

...Brief Case EC-Chicken cuts. FACT : Nguyên đơn : Brazil, Thái Lan Bị đơn: Ủy Ban các Cộng Đồng Châu Âu ( Ủy Ban Châu Âu – EC ) Bên thứ 3 : Trung Quốc , Hoa Kỳ Ngày 11 tháng 10 năm 2002, Brazil đã yêu cầu tham vấn với Cộng đồng châu Âu liên quan đến Quy định số 1223/2002 của Hội đồng EC (“quy định số 1223/2002”), ngày 8 tháng 07 năm 2002, mô tả sản phẩm thịt gà rút xương cắt miếng đông lạnh theo nhóm sản phẩm kết hợp mã CN 0207.14.10. Theo Brazil, mô tả này có đưa muối – thành phần không có - vào sản phẩm, và trong lộ trình cắt giảm thuế của Cộng đồng Châu Âu theo GATT 1994, sản phẩm nhập khẩu này chịu mức thuế cao hơn mức thuế của sản phẩm thịt muối (mã CN 0210). - T THẤY KO ỔN !! − Các dữ kiện chính của vụ việc ? (Facts) − Vấn đề đặt ra cho cơ quan xét xử để giải quyết ? (Issues) − Cơ sở pháp lý để giải quyết ? (Law) − Kết luận của cơ quan giải quyết tranh chấp ? (Holdings) − Lập luận chính của cơ quan giải quyết tranh chấp để đưa đến kết luận ? (Reasoning ISSUES : - Brazil cho rằng hành động đó thể hiện sự đối xử thiếu thiện chí đối với thương mại của Brazil, không như lộ trình cắt giảm thuế của Cộng đồng Châu Âu, và vi phạm cam kết của Cộng đồng châu Âu theo các Điều II và XXVIII của GATT 1994. - Brazil khiếu nại rằng biện pháp này của Cộng đồng châu Âu làm tổn hại, theo định nghĩa của Điều XXIII:1, đến lợi nhuận Brazil có thể thu được một cách trực tiếp hoặc gián tiếp theo quy định của GATT 1994. - Trong vụ kiện, Thái Lan cho rằng các nhà xuất khẩu thịt gà......

Words: 855 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Case of South Africa

...Question 2 Read the closing case “South Africa after the World Cup”. Discuss South Africa’s emergence on the world stage and the problems it has encountered during this emergence from the perspective of the following questions: (a) As an emerging market, South Africa was able to reap the benefits of the World Cup. How would you describe the World Cup effect on South Africa? Answer - Have boosted the country’s economy including hotel and tourism industry, retailing industry. - Have lowered the unemployment rate as the has created lots of job opportunities (e.g. rebuild the stadium, need more staff to serve the tourist, need more hostel for tourist to live in - Have draw foreign people’s attention on the country - From website: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/10507663 World Cup 'rebrands' South African economy By Bill WilsonBusiness reporter, BBC News 'Reputational boost' "South Africans are very proud of what we have done here, it has been a fantastic event, from an economic and a unity perspective," says Lee-Anne Bac, director at Grant Thornton Strategic Solutions in Johannesburg. "Hosting the 2010 World Cup will radically alter the landscape for tourism in southern Africa. "There has also been a reputational boost for South Africa that can help bring inward investment and visitors. "South Africa has been rebranding as a tourist destination and as one based around the development of a global sports event business model." Experts believe the......

Words: 1329 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Made in the Usa

...Made in the U.S.A- Dumped in Brazil, Africa, Iraq… In an uncertain world, capital budgeting attempts to determine what the future of a new product will bring and how then to act on that forecast. We never know for certain what the future will bring, but we do arrive at some idea of what the distribution of possible outcomes looks like. Unfortunately, when there is uncertainty, the outcome is not always a good one. For example, what happens if the government rules that our product is not safe? The answer is that we must abandon the product. The question then becomes what to do with the inventory we currently have on hand. We certainly want to deal with it in a way that is in the best interests of our shareholders. We also want to obey the law and act ethically. As with most ethical questions, there is not necessarily a right or wrong answer. The Case of ‘Made in The U.S.A.- Dumped in Brazil, Africa, Iraq…’ brings up the controversial issues of dumping, a term that refers to the practice of exporting to other countries products that have been banded or declared hazardous in the United States. Is it moral to dump U.S. banned products overseas? Both the manufactures and the consumers have valid arguments. As a consumer of these dangerous products being dumped on overseas markets one could argue the manufacturers lack of respect for life. It should be in the company’s best interest to take in consideration the health and safety of people and animals. These manufactures are......

Words: 705 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Brazil Case Country Document

...Bryce Walker-Byrd Case Country: Brazil The country I have selected to for this particular case country project is Brazil. I have never visited this country, however, its abundant and fascinating qualities have always intrigued me. From the intricate cuisine to the astonishingly beautiful women it contains, Brazil seems to almost rival the United States in diversity and appeal. The country has also begun to establish itself as one of the largest economy’s in the world, ranking seventh according to the GDP. Despite all of these qualities that have furthered my desire to visit this wonderful city, I never took into account its diversity and intrigue from an agricultural perspective. With me being a business marketing major, it came as almost instinct to view Brazil from its financial and business aspects. However, in order to fully appreciate this country and its emerging financial power, one must first look at the underlining factors, such as its process of achieving agricultural sustainability. Although there is certainly a correlation between Brazil’s booming economy and its conscious efforts in achieving ultimate agricultural sustainability, this particular document will be mostly geared towards the agricultural component of this relationship. More specifically, I plan to address connection between Brazil’s pursuit of agricultural sustainability and the rising levels of deforestation and land distribution inequality occurring in the country. In order to effectively......

Words: 811 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Case for Apple to Be Made in the U.S.A.

...code of conduct and fail to comply with social accountability. As mentioned in both Duhigg’s articles, although Apple creates huge profits with the support of Chinese suppliers, it is selling products with “conflicts”. Products with conflicts can hurt Apple’s image and might even trigger the market to boycott Apple’s products. By manufacturing in the U.S., Apple can avoid this problem and minimize the risk of producing products with conflicts. 2. The gap between U.S. wages and Chinese wages will narrow as Chinese wages rise (Schonberger). In 2011, Shanghai’s minimum wage increased 14%, and it will increase by another 13% starting in April (Zheng). With wages rising, the cost of manufacturing in China will also rise. Cheap labor has made China’s manufacturing industry almost undefeatable, but when it’s not so cheap anymore, it may be a good time for Apple to bring manufacturing jobs back to America, which offers a stable and highly productive labor market. 3. Foreign companies often find it difficult to navigate Chinese laws and government regulations when investing in China, and that can cause many unnecessary troubles. In China, regulations can change overnight and cause losses for businesses. Compared with China, the U.S. provides a much more stable and safe investment environment, which is ultimately better for a company’s long-term development. Therefore, Apple should definitely take this factor into consideration. 4. Currently, Chinese suppliers and their......

Words: 1604 - Pages: 7