Premium Essay

Abandoning Innovation in Emerging Industries

In: Business and Management

Submitted By robbot
Words 12590
Pages 51
Abandoning Innovation in Emerging Industries*

Rajshree Agarwal College of Business University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign 350 Wohlers Hall, 1206 S. Sixth Street Champaign, IL 61822 Voice: (217) 265-5513 Barry L. Bayus Kenan-Flagler Business School University of North Carolina CB 3490 Chapel Hill, NC 27599 Voice: (919) 962-3210 Mary Tripsas Harvard Business School Soldiers Field Road Boston, MA 02163 Voice: (617) 495-8407 Preliminary Draft September, 2005

All authors contributed equally and are listed in alphabetical order. The paper has benefited from comments made by seminar participants at the Harvard Business School. All remaining errors are ours.


Abandoning Innovation in Emerging Industries

Abstract Existing models of industry evolution describe a smooth pattern of emergence over time in which the number of firms in an industry increases, hits a peak, decreases as a result of a shakeout, and then stabilizes as the industry reaches maturity. Although this model has been well-accepted and the basic empirical finding holds true across a range of industries, we propose that the finding is not as robust as is generally assumed. We introduce an alternative pattern of evolution in which, during the emergent stage, an industry experiences a sharp decrease in the number of firms – a “mini shakeout” – before increasing again, reaching a final peak and undergoing a major shakeout as described in the extant literature. Using panel data across multiple product innovations introduced in the 20th century, we first show the pervasiveness of the mini shakeout phenomena. We then examine why some industries are more likely to experience a mini shakeout. Finally, using detailed quantitative and qualitative data on the emergence of handheld computers and digital cameras, we investigate why some firms abandon…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Innovation Diffusion in Mobile Communication Industry

...Innovation Diffusion in Mobile Communication Industry Introduction The word innovation is derived from the Latin word ‘innovatio’ which means renew or change. Innovation is connected with the renewal or improvement in things, it brings a change in the existing things or brings completely new thing into the market and the consequence of innovation is novelty. Innovation is that idea, practice or object which is perceived as new by an individual of unit of adoption (Rogers 1962). Innovation, first of all influences the thinking process of an individual, when one changes the way he makes a decision or makes choices outside of their norm. When innovation comes it changes the old settings and develops a space for new and better process and establishes a completely better system. Innovation and creativity are somewhere connected with each other; creativity can be described as coming up with new ideas, while innovation is about instilling life to ideas that is actually implementing the ideas. Innovation can be described differently at different levels, like on the lower level it is about changing the way the activities are performed and application of inventions; on the other hand, at the higher levels, it is about complete transformation of the organisation. In context to the organisation, innovation is concerned with positive changes in market shares, efficiency, competitive positioning, and quality productivity and so on and all these......

Words: 5006 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Innovation, Adapt to Change and Productivity Interrelationship in Telecommunications Industry

...| Innovation, Adapt to change and Productivity interrelationship in Telecommunications Industry. | Article Summary | for Economic Analysis(ECO740) | | | Prepared for: ASSOC. PROF. DR. AZIZ SULAIMAN Introduction The Telecommunications industry is currently undergoing changes due to globalization and new technological developments. Links between technologies within the technological system will change over time and affect the structure of the industrial network and firm behavior. Thus, organizations that successfully align service roles with advanced information technology can achieve comparative advantages in the marketplace (Youngdahl and Loomba, 2000). The deregulation and privatization of Malaysia’s telecommunications sector leads to technological innovation in the sector. Two forces drive the sector, namely technological innovation which drives the developed or matured markets; and technological diffusion which drives the developing or emerging ones (Telekom Malaysia Berhad, 2006). There is a need to adapt to developments in the global economy and local environment to strengthen the financial position and enhance service competitiveness (Telekom Malaysia Berhad, 2004). Thus, achieving the right service quality is important as it is the driving force for productivity and profitability. Good service could be achieved through empowerment (Tschohl, 1998) and the staff ability to produce more, adapt to changing technologies and to be......

Words: 1297 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Business Group Networks and Group Innovation in Emerging Markets

...Business Group Networks and Group Innovation in Emerging Markets Business groups, a constellation of legally independent firms operating under common administrative and financial management and connected by various types of ties, have been recognized as an important innovation powerhouse in emerging markets such as Korea and Taiwan(Chang, Chung, & Mahmood, 2006; Mahmood & Mitchell, 2004; Mahmood & Singh, 2003). Given the pervasive networks between business group members (Hamilton, 1996), scholars have assigned an important role to intra-group networks in understanding where the innovativeness of business group arises in emerging markets. Particularly, scholars have focused on three most commonly observed types of ties in business groups, i.e., buyer-supplier ties, equity ties and interlocking director ties (Belenzon & Berkovitz, 2010; Khanna & Rivkin, 2006; Mahmood, Zhu, & Zajac, 2011). Specifically, buyer-supplier ties within business groups connect firms engaged in commercial transactions and enable them to transfer production materials and market information across firm boundaries. Equity ties connect group members who hold equity stakes in each other through cross-shareholdings, providing a channel for the transfer of financial investment and control. Finally, director ties connect group members as they share the same individuals on the boards, and hence enable group members to coordinate strategies and governance (Mahmood et al., 2011). One explanation on how......

Words: 1186 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Factor Endowment Analysis of an Emerging Industry of Bangladesh

...interconnected firms, suppliers, related industries, and institutions that arise in particular locations. As a rule Competitive Advantage of nations has been the outcome of 4 interlinked advanced factors and activities in and between companies in these clusters. These interlinked advanced factors for Competitive Advantage for countries or regions in Porters Diamond framework are: Emerging industries in Bangladesh: Industrialization is now being encouraged in Bangladesh from different aspects. As a result different industries are emerging as contributing sector of our economy nowadays. Among these emerging industries significant industries are namely- IT Industry, Call Center Industry, Jute Manufacturing Products Industry, Pharmaceuticals Industry, Car Parts Producing Industry, Hospital Furniture Manufacturing Industry, FARR ceramics Industry, Ship Building Industry, Footwear Manufacturing Industry, Sports Wear Producing Industry, Garments Industry and so on. Here IT Service & Software Industry’s factor endowments are being discussed by using the Porter’s Diamond Framework. IT Service & Software Industry in Bangladesh IT & Software is one of the most talked about but unexploited industries in Bangladesh. Last two decades have seen lot of initiatives, both in public and private sector, to stimulate growth in this sector. IT industry in Bangladesh has come a long way over the last few decades. The industry has become dynamic with a significant......

Words: 1474 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Evaluating Emerging Opportunities in Uk's Health Spa Industry

...Evaluating Emerging Opportunities in UK’s Health Spa Industry Abstract The purpose of this report is to research the Indian Spa company, ISC’s potential on the UK’s market. The findings gave both positive and negative answers in terms of the research question: Should ISC enter the UK Health market? The SLEPT analysis led us to conclude that ISC could potentially handle the macro environment of UK well. The market analysis showed the astonishing market potential availability in the country. The firm’s human capital, external network and financial health showed that the company is well equipped to potentially run a subsidiary within UK. Thus the advice to ISC is, therefore: enter the UK Health market. ISC (Indian Spa Company) is a fictional company. General Country Information The United Kingdom is a constitutional monarchy and unitary state consisting of four countries: England, Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales. It is governed by a parliamentary system with its seat of government in London. The UK is a developed country, with the world's sixth largest economy by nominal GDP and the sixth largest by purchasing power parity. It was the world's first industrialised country and the world's foremost power during the 19th and early 20th centuries, but the economic and social cost of two world wars and the decline of its empire in the latter half of the 20th century diminished its leading role in global affairs. The UK nevertheless remains a great power......

Words: 1395 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

History of the Evolution and Emerging Trends of the Indian Tourism and Lodging Industry.

...Southern & Eastern Part of India. | January 16 2014 | History of the evolution and emerging Trends of the Indian Tourism and lodging Industry. | | NAME | Student No | Sushil Gujar | 6894422 | Jacob Jose Moolan | 6908420 | Roshan Shetty | 6657332 | Abstract The hospitality and tourism industry in India has largely diversified and has greatly complimented to the GDP as well as employment in major parts of India. Due to its rich heritage and culture it has recorded tremendous growth over the past years thus making it global tourist destination. With development in major hospitality projects and international brands setting its business in India, has led to the prosperity of the Hospitality industry. By providing you a glimpse about major tourist destination and hotels that contribute majorly to the growth of the industry, this report would provide you an insight on the hospitality industry in the southern and the eastern part of India. Contents Introduction 3 Southern part ofIndia 4 Kerala tourism 4 Munnar 4 Cochin 5 Kumarakom 5 Karnataka Tourism 5 Srirangapatana 5 Hampi 6 Mysore 6 Tamil Nadu Tourism 7 Ooty 7 Kanyakumari 7 Pondicherry tourism 8 Lodging and Hotels in South India 8 Taj Group of hotels 8 Oberoi Hotels and Resorts 8 ITC Group of hotels 9 Eastern part of India 10 Bhubaneswar 10 Ranchi 10 Gangtok 10 Kolkata 11 Result/ Conclusion 12 Reference 13 Introduction India consists of 29 states...

Words: 2415 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Innovation in the Fashion Industry

...      Innovation in the Fashion Industry:  A Study of Four Cases                      1  Table of Content Introduction Page 3  Page 3  Page 3  Page 5  Page 6  Page 6  Page 8  Page 10  Page 12  Page 13  Page 14      The history of fashion Major trends and developments in fashion Company Selection Analysis of the Companies House of Einstein Zara Fragile TOMS Conclusion Teamwork References Appendix           2  Introduction  The history of fashion  In  order  to  fully  understand  where   the  fashion   industry  stands  today  in  terms  of  organizational  forms  and  strategies,  we   first   look  at  the  transformation  this  industry  has  gone  through.  This  paragraph   will   analyze  the  changes  that  have  occurred   in  the  fashion  apparel  industry   in  the  past  century.   We  will  also  discuss  some  of the  major trends that are visible in the fashion industry today.  Up  until  the   1960s,   the  fashion   industry  was  roughly  divided  into  two  groups.   First there  were firms which  were  based   on  mass  production,  with   low  costs  and  standardized  styles that  did not change  frequently  (Bhardwaj  &  Fairhust,  2010).  During  this time, a  large group  of  consumers  was less sensitive  to  fashion  and had  a preference  for  practical,  basic   apparel.   Secondly  there  was  the  luxury  fashion  industry,   which  originated  in  France.  A  small  group  of  French......

Words: 6995 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

Emerging Issues in the Tourism Industry

...Emerging Issues in the Tourism Industry (In case of Switzerland) Introduction According to the World Economic Forum's annual Travel & Tourism Competitiveness Report which was released at the Global Tourism Forum (GTF) in Andorra; Switzerland and some other countries were considered as the most beautiful environments for developing the tourism and travel industries. Tourism always plays a vital role in the economy of any country and it plays the same role in Switzerland. But, it has been struck by the economic condition in Switzerland, because of the world economic recession. Tourists come to Switzerland because of its natural beauty, but with the continuing strike in many areas of Switzerland; it results in the improvement of tourism in Switzerland in recent years. Tourism Growth "Our report measures different factors that make it beautiful to make the tourism and travel industry of one country," said Jennifer Blanke, Lead Director and Economist of the World Economic Forum's Centre for Global Performance and Competitiveness. "The top rankings countries Switzerland, France, Germany and Austria show the significance of regulatory frameworks and supportive business, matched with world-class tourism and transport infrastructure, and a focus on rising natural and human resources for increasing an environment that is beautiful for making the tourism and travel sector." This analysis of the cross-country of the drivers of competitiveness in tourism and travel offers......

Words: 5566 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Strategic Innovation Management in Global Industry Networks

...Organization, 2010 Submitted date: August 30, 2010 Accepted date: October 09, 2010 Published date: December 10, 2010 Strategic Innovation Management in Global Industry Networks: The TFT LCD Industry Guenter Boehm and 2 L.J. Fredericks Strategic Marketing, Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd., Yongin-449-711, South Korea 2 The Center of Poverty and Development Studies, Faculty of Economics and Administration, University of M alaya, Kuala Lumpur-5060 3, M alaysia 1 1 Abs tract: This study examines the strategic innovation management of the business creation process across the technology industry value chain in the global thin-film-transistor (TFT) liquid-crystal-display (LCD) industry based on an anonymous online survey of employees in the industry value chain and outside exp erts (universities, consultants, etc.). The study confirms that technology strategy formulation and a strategic center position are key industry concerns. It also affirms the utility of the industry value chain framework to manage technological innovations transcending that of a single company, and that strategic innov ation m anag eme nt in global high technology industries incorporates a shared business creation process structure involving as many industry value chain partners as possible. Key words: Global high technology industry networks, strategic innovation manageme nt, TFT L CD industry INTRODUCTION Globalization, de-regulation an d inno vative communication technologies have radically transformed the......

Words: 7166 - Pages: 29

Free Essay

Mice: Emerging as the Profit Segment for the Industry, by Karishma Sen

...Citation: MICE: EMERGING AS THE PROFIT SEGMENT FOR THE INDUSTRY, By Karishma Sen, T3 , May 14, 2013 INTRODUCTION Domestic and outbound travel has been the talk of not just Indian industry stalwarts but international ones as well. The mere statistics of tourism in India is enough to raise eyebrows and contribute to heated discussions that fuel a growing opinion of India’s tourism potential. The creeper that grows alongside this sector is MICE. Not only has it been contributing to a large chunk of the tourism sector, it has also grown leaps and bounds in quality, services and, most importantly, demand.. Following research questions have been addressed by this research paper: (1) What is the status of current Indian MICE industry ?? (2) Why only convention centres are enjoying to MICE business ?? (3) Significant contribution of MICE to Hotel business ?? (4) Challenges for India is becoming an exotic MICE destination in comparison with other countries. LITERATURE REVIEW According to International Congress & Convention Association (ICCA) statistics, a total of 400,000 conferences and exhibitions are held worldwide every year at the total outlay of US$280 billion, and India’s share is pegged only at US$4.8 bn. Currently, India ranks 27th in the global MICE market. According to International Congress & Convention Association (ICCA) statistics, a total of 400,000 conferences and exhibitions are held worldwide every year at the total outlay of US$280 billion, and India’s......

Words: 850 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Case 1- Usa Today: Innovation in an Evolving Industry

...way the printed edition is with bright colors and snippets of news. It was developed to keep up with the growing technology and in response to the slight decline in profits to the printed version. Also, like the printed version, the on-line version strives to create a partnership with its readers. The reason why I believe USA Today is so successful is it keeps capitalizing its marketing opportunities by listening to their readers. The width of the paper was changed to meet the needs of the business traveler; to make it easier to read on airplanes and to fit easier in a briefcase and started to offer a free search for archived articles with ability to download for a fee. 2. How has a continuous strategy of marketing innovation proved successful for USA Today and Do you believe that USA Today is well position for the future? Explain USA Today's original mission statement "To serve as a forum for better understanding and unity to help make the USA truly one nation." ( ) tells the reader exactly what the paper's direction is. In the beginning, USA Today was critiqued as a newspaper lightweight, considered a "McPaper-junk food journalism" (Ferrell, O., & Hartline, M., 2014) by its traditional brand competitors. The formula of short stories, bright graphics and bright summary boxes that looked like a TV with short snippets using short words was exactly what the readers were looking for. The new newspaper filled a gap . The......

Words: 1107 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Emerging Sales and Marketing Challenges in the Global Hospitality Industry

...Emerging sales and marketing challenges in the global hospitality industry Author: Rishi, Meghna; Gaur, Sanjaya S Abstract: Purpose - This paper attempts to identify the emerging themes that can shed light on the sales and marketing issues and challenges being faced by global hospitality organizations. Design/methodology/approach - The paper utilizes a multi-method approach for data collection. A thorough literature review, a focus group and personal interviews were conducted to explore the themes and construct a tentative thematic web. Publicly accessible secondary data in the form of customer reviews were drawn from world's leading web site - A total of 702 reviews of the customers of luxury hotels from the world's top two tourist destinations - France and USA - were analyzed, using thematic analysis. Customers' perspective is juxtaposed with industry's perspective to offer insights on the sales and marketing issues and challenges being faced by hospitality organizations globally. Findings - Marketing challenges, namely personalization/customization of services, service management, creating a strong parent brand, under-utilization of the social media and diverting tourists from heritage properties, are identified as some of the key emerging sales and marketing issues and challenges faced by the global hospitality industry. Practical implications - Analytically identified themes in this research paper provide valuable insights on issues and......

Words: 489 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Usa Today: Innovation in an Evolving Industry

...Richard Godfrey BMKT 6311 USA Today Case Study The newspaper publishing industry is one of the most rapidly evolving industries in the world today. Changing due to economic climate shift, consumer needs evolving, enhanced technology, and continuous competition; USA Today has been able to succeed. The publication raises the bar through innovation and value-added content to bolster their standing in the publishing world as “The Nation’s Newspaper” in hopes of staying continually relevant and standing out amongst the competition, ensuring the future of the USA Today brand. 1) When Gannett first debuted USA Today in 1982, the corporation took advantage of a multitude of opportunities in the marketing environment and secured a strong foothold in a market that already had several major players. The most impactful opportunity, in my opinion, is its format. In an attempt to stand out from the competition, USA Today developed a unique format of shorter pieces with photos, graphs, charts in order to address the needs of an audience other publications seemingly ignored. By creating a product high in form utility, the publication was able to distinguish itself and cater to an evolving market. Gannett also cited watching trends and evolution of news readers as part of the success. As society shifted to having typically shorter attention spans, yet still having a hunger for knowledge, Gannett capitalized on these trends with the updated format of USA Today targeted towards the......

Words: 1685 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Disruptive Innovation in Emerging Markets: Strategies Used

... Disruptive Innovation in Emerging Markets: Strategies Used in India and China Ruan Y., Hang C.C., Subramanian A.M. No. 01/12 Division of Engineering & Technology Management (D-ETM) Institute of Engineering Leadership (IEL) Faculty of Engineering 1    Disruptive Innovation in Emerging Markets: Strategies Used in India and China Ruan Y., Hang C.C., Annapoornima M.S. Abstract The appropriate type of innovation which can meet the needs of the mass population in the bottom of pyramid (BOP) has not been studied much in the literature. Based on the theory of disruptive innovation, we offer 11 cases from India and China – the two biggest emerging markets to show that disruptive innovation could be an appropriate, feasible, and powerful innovation force to the companies and the economies involved. We also examined the R&D strategies used in these cases based on the framework proposed by Yu & Hang (2011) and found that 3 out of the 4 strategies commonly used in the cases from developed markets were also applied in the cases from emerging markets. In addition, we have identified 3 unique strategies which emerged from the cases from India and China, namely frugal engineering, modularization, and drastic manufacturing cost reduction. Based on the frequency of the usage of these strategies, we drew practical implications for local companies and multinational companies. Our study also provides critical insights to policy makers in emerging markets on......

Words: 10301 - Pages: 42

Premium Essay

Emerging Nokia

...Emerging Nokia Case Study JANUARY 3, 2012 Defining the Nature of the Problem The nature of global markets has been rapidly changing in the last twenty – twenty five years. These changes to a great degree have been determined by the major breakthroughs in the geopolitical makeup of the world. One of the pivotal events that fueled the economic changes around the globe was the collapse of the communist bloc in the beginning of the 1990s and consequently the dismantling of the bi-polar world order that had been previously characterized not only by two antagonistic ideologies, but also by two incompatible and mostly isolated from each other marketplaces. The description of that old world order was often referred to as “the free and the communist world”, “the West and the East”, which later morphed into” developed and developing” countries. As the pure and acute ideological  division of the world has moved to the fringes of the global agenda, leaving the front stage of the world community focus to the global economic, ecologic and broader humanitarian challenges, the new world paradigm has been more and more often referred to as “developed and emerging economies”. The playing out of these new global realities is very vividly represented by the nature of the challenges and the business decisions required of the executives of the world-renown engineering and telecommunications giant – Nokia, which is mostly known to the world for its leading role in the mobile phone handsets......

Words: 1238 - Pages: 5